'A Christmas Carol' Movie Review - New York Post

The Post's Kyle Smith says this animated version of the classic story is a misfire. http://video.nypost.com

Category:

Film & Animation

Tags:

• kyle smith
• movie review
• a christmas carol
• disney
• animation
• jim carrey
• new york
• nypost.com

[YouEminent]

NY Post hates everything that wasn't produced by Fox.

[iCHRISshow]

that guy sucks at reviewing

[hackensac]

this guy's a wimp. "Too many scary parts." It's a Christmas Carol not the care bears.

I did hate the shrinking part. It took away all the scariness of the GOCF away

[CClassACT]

These review are crap, how about you look at it from the target audience idiots, oh its not this, its not that, its a family/ kid film, not com complex mid benter god.

[ClankClaw]

Critic is short for critasiser people..... I think =P

[kangaroo9123]

i honestly think these reviews are the shittiest reviews ive ever seen, you guys seem to have no feeling and are obviously 50 year old men WHO ISNT THE TARGET AUDIENCE AT ALL.....so fuck these reviews i hope they stop maikn them, PEACE FUCKER

[JPM2875]

My favorite version will always be the Patrick Stewart TNT version

[nikilinn09]

tHIS MOVIE TOOKS SO GOOD!?!? I HAVE ONLY SEEN PEOPLE SAY GOOD THINGS ABOUT IT OH MAYBE IT'S SCARY, BUT NOT BAD?? I LOVE POLAR EXPRESS & JIM CARREY SO YOUR REVIEW WILL NOT STOP ME & I DON'T THINK OTHERS HERE AGREE WITH YOU YET!!

=]~

[MysteryMom3]

I completely disagree with your review. Did we actually see the same movie? Do you know anything about animation, mocap, technology? The story was great and this was an unbelievable technical achievement and a beautiful film to watch. In my opinion, this movie is a 5/5 and I highly recommend it and will be seeing it again soon.

[Leonnidik]

Stick with that old English version from the 30's.