Confused Matthew & SFDebris Discuss Star Trek (2009) 1 of 5

The audio quality isn't perfect, but I hope you all enjoy this.

Visit SFDebris at http://www.youtube.com/sfdebris

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• confusedmatthew
• confused
• matthew
• sfdebris
• star
• trek
• 2009
• review
• discussion
• jj
• abrams

[GreenTeaGarlic]

If I were the captain of a Romulan mining ship, I would love Spock for TRYING to save my family. A better story would have been if Spock had a choice to save either Vulcan or Romulus, and he chooses Vulcan. THAT would justifiably piss him off enough to do what he did.

[Williamsfan]

Right.

It pushed them away.

Without blowing them up.

Even though for all we know they have no power source for their sheilds.

I take it back, this isn't even treknobabble. This is just lazy writing.

[tuschman168]

@Dilandau3000 Thank you!

[Dilandau3000]

@tuschman168 SFDebris's official Star Trek 2009 review will be released on the 31st of December.

[Dilandau3000]

Rewatching this to compare it with SFDebris's upcoming real review. :)

[gameboxfreak]

@AliTubelog

"Star Trek II: The wrath of Khan" is evidence to the contrary.

[danceoutnow]

here is my problem with people who tore down the newest star trek movie. The point of this movie was not just a "love letter" to the character of kirk (though was not happy with the spock and Uhura romance. The big piece that all the writers wanted to include was Gene Roddenberry's original concept and character (which was rejected) of Christopher Pike, and to tie that into the formation of TOS's crew. They did that, though they should not have killed spock's mom an used the time theory.

[AliTubelog]

StarTrek was never meant to be a movie

Picard is disappointed.

/thread

[tuschman168]

Is this SF debris' review of star trek 2009? Sorry, I know to many this must be an incredibly stupid question but I have actually just discovered his website. (Yes, I seem to be new to the internet. Laugh it up, guys.) On his website the reviews seem to stop at Star trek 10. Am I just blind or has he just not gotten around to do it, yet?

[davideshafer]

This movie spent most of its time establishing the characters and the universe. So I'm ok with the story sicken a Fay one.

[ltflak]

I like Final Frontier, you can pretend it never existed. Generations...ick, there's no getting rid of that shit. Enterprise will stay dead, Kirk will always have that shitty death, out of the 11 movies, Generations is the biggest disservice to Star Trek

[Eldeecue]

@jessemaurais

Yes, it is. Honestly it's worse than Generations. Generations you can at least fall asleep to while watching. Final Frontier is just so disjointed and spasmic that you can't even properly be bored with it.