Mordechai Kedar: Demography in Judea and Samaria

Mordechai Kedar spoke at an event entitled, "Israeli Sovereignty Over Judea and Samaria" on June 20, 2011 in Israel. The event was produced and sponsored by Yoel Meltzer and Ted Belman of Israel Pundit. This footage provided by Paris David Blumenthal.

Category:

Nonprofits & Activism

Tags:

• Judea
• and
• Samaria
• Kedar

[Lagolop]

But why should Jews have to give away ANY of their land. Fuck the world, and Israel should not apologize for keeping itself safe and it's land whole. Israel already got screwed out of a huge chunk of it's land .... it's now called Jordan.

[Toby351]

I believe that this is a realistic and applicable solution.

We can always try it, it doesn't demand changes and nobody is uprooted

[ahmedizm]

why not fragment israel !!!!!! ,am so disappointed that this speach come from who is suppose to be an educated man !!!!

[taniajosefa]

thank you dr keidar. excellent idea. should be disseminated.

however

palestinians have been influenced to dream of a national state, although they are not one nationality.

their professed belief in arab unity may prevent them from admitting that they prefer tribal (racist) sovereignty.

could this system really obviate their devotion towards the idea of replacing israel from the river to the sea as an arab version of israel, notwithstanding the realistic unlikelihood of such a state?

[Lagolop]

@jdiamo91

"Kedar's solution solves both issues."

He makes good points. I just don't see it working in reality. I do not think there is anything Israel could do to make nay arabs happy except dissolve. And that will not happen anytime soon. That is my point.

[jdiamo91]

@Lagolop

Wow, I'm sorry I thought I could even have a dialogue with such a disciple person like yourself. Your vile talk is so un-Jewish, you ought to be ashamed of yourself.

The fact of the matter is that Palestinians aren't going anywhere, whether you like it or not. Like Kedar said, we need to avoid creating another "Hamastan" while at the same time being realistic about DEMOGRAPHIC threats. Kedar's solution solves both issues.

[Lagolop]

@jdiamo91

Kedar has a good point, I agree and it is logical but I just cant stomach the thought of caving into those cunts.

[Lagolop]

@jdiamo91

PS I can't even see what I originally wrote. I think it may have been removed. Not sure but I can tell you that I can;t see what my original post was. can you repost it if you see it so I can see what I originally wrote.

[Lagolop]

@jdiamo91

My mistake. Meant to wrote

Get rid of the lot of "palis". They would NEVER allow a Jew to live on arab land; why should the Jews allow them to live on Jewish land? The palis are the same ppl that want Israel utterly destroyed, why give them an inch of Jewish land?

[Lagolop]

@jdiamo91

I have a better idea. Clear every muslim out of the land of Israel. They don't belong there. Why give those false ppl any Jewish land. Message =

"You are right, maybe Jews do not belong there".

Get rid of the lot of "palis". They would NEVER allow a Jew to live on arab land; why should the Jews allow them, that Israel utterly destroyed, to live on 1 inch of Jewish land? No matter what u give them the palis will NEVER be happy ... period. Get them all off of those Jewish highlands.

[jdiamo91]

@Lagolop

So what is the matter with Kedar's solution?? No Jews will have to be evacuated like in Katif, and the hills will go to Israel -- no security issues. And besides, do really want to hold on to Ramallah, Bethlehem, Jenin? Those cities aren't Jewish and they never will be. Why absorb all of those Palestinians? Kedar's creative thinking is much better than the absurd, suicidal one-state solution you clearly adhere to.