I agree with Willyum1000. I have not heard the 2000 recordings he refers to, but it is a pity that a singer with such a respiration capacity and sound capabilities, just stands there singing without acting (both with voice and face). I mean he could be singing anything; as my teacher would say "singing is the art of moving, not of astonishing"
you seem to assume verdi is all about bellowing - i wonder if anyone agrees with you? anyway, to educate you a little more about shtoda, whom i have been following since he began: listen to his 2000 cd of russian songs & then compare with his 2005 cd of russian opera arias: you will see one is poetic, sensitive & lyrical, the other..well just plain boring, particularly the lensky arioso, which demands intimate moments of hushed pianissimo. shtoda just wont or cant do that any more. very sad...
if any of you had heard shtoda's earlier cd of russian love songs, in which he sang so sensitively, so poetically & so lyrically, will be dissappointed that he has become just another 'can belto' singer who can only sing everything fortissimo...what a waste of a voice!!
Привет из Санкт-Петербурга! Я счастлива тем что слушаю его в Мариинском театре, а также в филармонии и на других сценах!!!
liuboviza1ify 6 months ago
Wonderful singing
robmanrico 1 year ago
He has the notes but not the style.
raythespian 1 year ago
This is great!!! Bravo!!!
TenoreMKD 2 years ago
i think it doesn´t exist souch a thing. it´s not his repertoire.
enricodicapri 2 years ago
I agree with Willyum1000. I have not heard the 2000 recordings he refers to, but it is a pity that a singer with such a respiration capacity and sound capabilities, just stands there singing without acting (both with voice and face). I mean he could be singing anything; as my teacher would say "singing is the art of moving, not of astonishing"
EnricoAtHome 2 years ago
you seem to assume verdi is all about bellowing - i wonder if anyone agrees with you? anyway, to educate you a little more about shtoda, whom i have been following since he began: listen to his 2000 cd of russian songs & then compare with his 2005 cd of russian opera arias: you will see one is poetic, sensitive & lyrical, the other..well just plain boring, particularly the lensky arioso, which demands intimate moments of hushed pianissimo. shtoda just wont or cant do that any more. very sad...
willyum1000 2 years ago
That is bullcrap! You can´t compare singing Verdi, where he must sing over an Orchestra VS singing Tchaikovsky over a pianoforte!
kkm3000 2 years ago
does anyone have a vid of him singing E Lucevan Le Stelle?
sionnachy 2 years ago
if any of you had heard shtoda's earlier cd of russian love songs, in which he sang so sensitively, so poetically & so lyrically, will be dissappointed that he has become just another 'can belto' singer who can only sing everything fortissimo...what a waste of a voice!!
willyum1000 2 years ago