That is what you understand from the hadith.Great Imams like Imam Syafie rhm, Imam Nawawi and Imam Ibnu hajar Asqalany all said Bid'ah is given in two forms.I am sure you are aware of the hadith where sayidina Umar r.a said "This is a Good Bid'ah." When they prayed tarawih under one Imam.I have many more proofs.If you say Bi'dah is bad in nature or in language then Sayidina Umar r.a would not have used that word to describe it.Simple as that.
A Bid3a means, that something is an innovation. An innovation is leading to hellfire. The hadith says something like? ''Every new matter is an innovation and every innovation is misguidance.” You say things like: Good and Bad Bid3a..
EVERY BID3A is bad, or didn't Islam came in a PERFECT way, in a PERFECT form? In every khutbah you hear the Hadith...
Bi'dah does'nt mean something bad.It just means something new.If you say Maulid is a Bid'ah, I agree with you but It's a GOOD Bid'ah.
Bid'ah comes in two forms, Good Bid'ah and Bad Bid'ah. Imam Syafie rhm said this.
There are many Mujtahid Scholars before us that said Maulid is allowed so it's best you don't condemn their words and learn to respect them.If you don't celebrate then it's ok, just keep it to yourself.
@imsmarteven basically if you wanna celebrate the birth of the prophet pbuh you should fast every monday, many muslims dont do this as its just easier to celebrate the birth of the Prophet pbuh annually. Monday was the day the Prophet pbuh was born, the Prophet pbuh or sahaaba didnt practice an annual celebration.
@RoadToJennah
Bring me a hadith that says celebrating maulid is Against the Shariah.
Reinabil 2 days ago
@Reinabil
Okay..
But Mawlid an Nabi is against the Shariah, so .. these words has to been fit in the right place there.
RoadToJennah 2 days ago
@RoadToJennah
The hadith states "ma laisa minhu",What ever that we are doing are not against the syariah.It doesnt go against the syariah.
Reinabil 3 days ago
@Reinabil
Show me the proofs :)
I like to learn. But I never hear about the things you say, so..
RoadToJennah 3 days ago
@Reinabil
Narrated Aisha:
Allah's Apostle said, "If somebody innovates something which is not in harmony with the principles of our religion, that thing is rejected."
'A'isha reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying:
He who innovates things in our affairs for which there is no valid (reason) (commits sin) and these are to be rejected.
RoadToJennah 3 days ago
@RoadToJennah
That is what you understand from the hadith.Great Imams like Imam Syafie rhm, Imam Nawawi and Imam Ibnu hajar Asqalany all said Bid'ah is given in two forms.I am sure you are aware of the hadith where sayidina Umar r.a said "This is a Good Bid'ah." When they prayed tarawih under one Imam.I have many more proofs.If you say Bi'dah is bad in nature or in language then Sayidina Umar r.a would not have used that word to describe it.Simple as that.
Reinabil 3 days ago
@Reinabil
A Bid3a means, that something is an innovation. An innovation is leading to hellfire. The hadith says something like? ''Every new matter is an innovation and every innovation is misguidance.” You say things like: Good and Bad Bid3a..
EVERY BID3A is bad, or didn't Islam came in a PERFECT way, in a PERFECT form? In every khutbah you hear the Hadith...
RoadToJennah 1 week ago
@RoadToJennah
Bi'dah does'nt mean something bad.It just means something new.If you say Maulid is a Bid'ah, I agree with you but It's a GOOD Bid'ah.
Bid'ah comes in two forms, Good Bid'ah and Bad Bid'ah. Imam Syafie rhm said this.
There are many Mujtahid Scholars before us that said Maulid is allowed so it's best you don't condemn their words and learn to respect them.If you don't celebrate then it's ok, just keep it to yourself.
Reinabil 1 week ago
@imsmarteven basically if you wanna celebrate the birth of the prophet pbuh you should fast every monday, many muslims dont do this as its just easier to celebrate the birth of the Prophet pbuh annually. Monday was the day the Prophet pbuh was born, the Prophet pbuh or sahaaba didnt practice an annual celebration.
atif1030 2 weeks ago
where is the full video? this is just another cut and paste.. He usually explains himself after!
Yasmin742 3 weeks ago