Uploader Comments (tauseefqau2)
All Comments (32)
-
far better than tina sani.....but nayyara noor and madhurani in my consent lie parallel........both are good at this one!!!!!
-
@tazzzzz999 - both renditions are very beautiful. Lets us not get into any India or Pakistan bashing here. Music and poetry are among the few things over which we unite. Let's please keep it that way. One upman-ship is best left to politicians, not music. this is utterly sublime singing- hats off to both the ladies. Nayyara-ji and Madhuraniji
-
oh wow!! i had heard of Madhurani from a friend who is an Ustad from Afghanistan. I know she is the Ustani of Peenaz Masani. Its amazing what treasures we have hidden midst us...
-
oh my god.. how nostalgic.. I remember she belonged to some raj gharana or some rich ancestory.. always composed and sang for her own content.. stayed away from limelite and commercial aspect of music industry.. though its our bad luck that we did'nt get much to hear from her.. or.. let us be optimistic and hope she sings again..
-
thanx a lot to d uploader,..madhu rani is such a great singer,.Finally got smthing to hear,..She had appeared in saregama as a guest judge and I was stunned to hear her live,..Plzz upload more if uve got more tracks of her
-
atiqa was an exceptional beauty...
-
srafiquemd seems has expressed his view that Nayyara noor is no where near this singer and probably his knowledge requires a lot of updating . I am from India and a very big fan of NN. She is a great singer with right quality of voice this singer in fact is know where near her. Lol.
-
I have been looking for this over fifteen years. Many thanks to the uploader.
-
here in lies the problem between indian singers and listeners and pakistani singers and liteners. when you make such an obscene comment ,that nayara noor is nowhere near this singer you obviously have no clue what ghazal is. while this is a classically trained singer she hasn't the depth in her voice to render justice to this kalam.listen to nayaras rendetion and you will see the difference , if you are pakistani or a urdu speaker.
#
srafiquemd
10 months ago
This does not seem to be Tina Sani's voice. This singer's gaiki is far superior than Tina Sani. Nayyera Noor is nowhere near this artist (whoever this is)
tauseefqau2 1 year ago
#
srafiquemd
1 year ago
Thanks for sharing this masterpiece ghazal. I have never heard Madhuri before but she is obviously a very well trained singer. She is better than most film singers we have had.
tauseefqau2 1 year ago