Jonas Kaufmann - Flower Song from Carmen
Uploader Comments (frufruJ)
Top Comments
-
WOW! The greatest ever pianissimo I've ever heard at Et j'étais une chose à toi (min. 3:45). Domingo sings this phrase at full voice; Carreras resorts to falsetto, but Kaufmann sings it in pure full voice in the most delicate pianissimo which reminds me of the great Franco Corelli who, inspite of the size of his voice could produce incredible and long diminuendos. It was about time someone like Kaufmann come alone and show that this technique doesn't belong only to great sopranos. Great document
All Comments (123)
-
He's too throaty for me.
-
that was....delicate, heart wrenching beauty that one hopes for .....bravo.
-
the voice and the man are To DIE FOR. That last poignant long note is everything in this piece, and he did it with all the emotionally delic
-
Well, this is definitely not Italianate singing.His voice would be much more suitable to Wagner and Richard Strauss.
As it is, for me it sounds too much sliding,the line is broken and "rewritten" sometimes, there are instances when he tries to overdo just to do differently.
You want the last sententences pianissimo? Try early Alagna.Although, to tell you the truth I prefer Caruso,Gedda and Pavarotti in this aria.
-
remarkable; i don't know a word of what he said but it touched me deeply.
-
Necesito más sentimiento y un canto menos plano para conquistarme, no obstante, el piannisimo del final es soberbio y, dado que Domingo es considerado un referente en este papel y lo da gritando (compatriota mío, pero una gran mentira de tenor, amigos, puro marketing), le doy mi voto positivo, al menos respeta la partitura que tantos pisotean.
-
This is very good even though for me it is not quite up to the version by Carreras.
-
A chocolate box tenor if ever I heard one, and beautiful with it!
-
He's good looking but he doesn't move me. The voice is too tough and his phrasing is too square for French or Italian music. And could anyone understand his French?
-
schlimm gesungen..
Jonas - Lithuanian name .... To German - Johann (like Bach). Sir Jonas, maybe you Lithuanian?
stepasb 1 year ago
@stepasb You are right that the Lithuanian Jonas is for Johann or John or Juan, but this is Jonas (in Czech we have Jan for Johann and Jonáš for Jonas :-) ) It comes from Hebrew, Jonah was the person who was swallowed by a whale in a Biblical story.
I love Wikipedia :-)
frufruJ 1 year ago 6