CELTIC WOMAN - GREATEST DVD VOL.5
Top Comments
All Comments (20)
-
@ddthienvuong. There are no "volumes" on the albums or DVDs. The Christmas album was the 2nd C.W album ever released (release date: October 19th, 2006), beating the release of Celtic Woman: A New Journey (release date: January 30th, 2007). Hayley joined C.W. at the Slane concert. She was on the 3rd album and although parts of the 4th (the "Greatest Journey" best-of album) were from Slane Castle, Hayley didn't necessarily perform on them.
-
@1sorryham 1st, the live performance of A Christmas Celebration was after the live at Slane, only the CD was released before it. seccond, I was asking that if Hayley was in the show at Slane, she should have recorded the songs for the album A New Journey before that, because that album was what the show at Slane was based on. However, at vol.4 - the recording of the album, it did not mention about her! while in this vol. about the live show, she appears! she's supposed to appear in both!
-
@ddthienvuong, No, the first performance was "Celtic Woman" (Live at the Helix). The second performance recorded was their Christmas one, again at the Helix. Hayley was not on the first two performances or albums. She became part of Celtic Woman for the live performance at Slane Castle in August of 2006, and she did a tour with Celtic Woman after that in 2007, but only one tour. After that, she was not part of the group.
-
@1sorryham The Live at Slane castle comes first, and the A New Journey album was based on it, the cd version includes some of the songs performed at the live show, the DVD version was basically the show itself filmed! vol. 5 (this one), is about the live show, the previous was about the album A New Journey, how come Hayley's in this vol but not the previous?
-
There was their debut album "Celtic Woman" and the DVD (Live at the Helix in Dublin). Their 2nd concert was "Celtic Woman: A Christmas Celebration" again done live at the Helix in Dublin. Hayley Westenra was not brought into Celtic Woman until their 3rd live concert/DVD production, "Celtic Woman: A New Journey: (Live at Slane Castle)". The 4th DVD was the 'best of" compilation "Greatest Journey", and Hayley is on that as well from her Slane Castle performance.
-
hmm, wierd, Hayley should have appeared at vol.4 too, right? I thought she also took part in the record?
-
I love Chloe's laugh at 2:50 :) the whole conversation before it just cracks me up :)
-
Lisa is really cool and awesome : )
OMG I love when Lisa asks Chloe if she knows her stuff yet and Chloe says "almost" and she calls her a Liar lol omg
cougarfan06 2 years ago 9
I love Lisa's laugh at 2:35
cougarfan06 2 years ago 8