JS Bach's Invention no. 13 in A Minor
Top Comments
All Comments (65)
-
With the simplified left hand, this no longer qualifies as an "invention."
Still, good beginner piece.
-
it sure is. im a lousy pianist, and i played this better 10 years ago.
-
terror and pain
-
very nice, best interpretation i heard on here. beginner or not i enjoyed the slow pace
-
Hey that was nice!!!!!!!!!! Can u put Invention in A minor by frederick silvester invention no.2
-
I agree with Belamus, totally.
As a pianist ... this is an insult to Bach to simplify his music.
BUT, the work done by this player is good :) Thanks for sharing, still !
-
Hey, there's no need to be rude :(
-
simplifying bach's music for beginners is the most moronic idea ever conceived by man. bach's music is perfect the way he wrote it. and yes, most of it, including his simplest keyboard works like the inventions, is quite challenging. his music is not for absolute beginners, and creating such versions of the music effectively amounts to bastardizing a master's work. shame on you for even thinking of doing this.
-
This has a very beautiful melody! Thanks.
Perhaps youtube users should read the notes to the right of the video, before posting comments about how wrong the piece is being played. Clearly it is a reference for beginners wanting to learn this song with a simplified bass-hand and slower tempo.
seansotheman 2 years ago 12
But with this simple version it gives a perfect window of opportunity for beginners to even begin to play this song..
Perfection comes later..
Play it now instead of not ever.. YES???
Also I bet you all mucho bucks that this piano player can play this piece very well and is only doing it simple to give people who want to learn it an idea of the base line and what to expect.. And give them a chance to learn it..
orangie84 2 years ago 7