So, Who's Right? (Shaykh Hasan Ali) Part 15/17

Click here for part 16: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3uKxmE_RXw

This is the best lecture i have heard on this subject and I 100% recommend it for all, to benefit from and spread.

Shaykh Hasan Ali delivers an amzingly clear and insightful discourse on the subject of 'division in the ummah' or rather Which group is the right? What are the factors? How to recognize the right group? What is difference of opinion? Can we have a united ummah? Hanafi? Salafi? Athari? Maturidi?

This talk was uploaded from Hikmah website (http://www.hikmah.co.uk) Please visit the site for HD version of this talk and for many more videos.

Click here for the full playlist: http://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=34545E7D27E05FC8

Brought to you by the Hanafi Fiqh channel.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• so
• whos
• right
• sheikh
• hasan
• ali
• shafi
• hanafi
• wahabi
• maliki
• athari
• ahle
• hadith
• hanbali
• deobandi
• jamati
• barelwi
• madkhali
• ikhwani
• tablighi
• salafi
• ashari
• maturidi
• madhab
• sufi
• fiqh
• quran
• sunnah
• and
• shaykh
• deoband
• darul
• uloom
• mufti
• taqi
• usmani
• riyadh
• ul
• haq
• ahmed
• jamat
• unity
• ummah
• bukhari
• muslim
• daleel
• aqidah
• sects
• kafir
• division
• takfeer
• dewsbury
• channel

[acejamal1]

cont..and sheer deviousness to pretend otherwise.

As regard to shia we do not call all shia kafir only those who commit kufr those for example who say" the goat ate ten chapters" are those who curse the shaykhain or those who say the angel Gibraeel made a mistake and should have gone to Ali our those who curse Umm al Mumineen.

Those who oppose the Aqeedah of Ahle Sunnah put thgem selvbes in a grave predicament!

We can not unite with such a people because they will always sell you out!!!

[acejamal1]

@scorpion32 Mirzai are Kafir 100% because they believe Mirza to be a prophet!

we do not call all deobandi kafir but anyone who has studied the books of ther so called scholars and reads where they have committed kufar and does not condemn the kufr in it himself because Kafir (kitab ul Kharaj Qazi Abu YUsaf) @to doubt kufr is kufar"

Ther is a difference between fiqh and Aqeeedah The Aima all had the same aqeedah they differed on the fruey Mas'ail which is the fiqh!

It is gross ignorance ...

[scorpion32]

@mo98183 brother with respect how can there be significant differences on the suicide bombing when there is a clear hadiths one which says if someone kills themselves they will be in hell dying the same way forever and another one where the prophet (saw) says the first group of people that the flames will be ignited on the day of judgement is the fake martyr /scholar/rich charity giver

[scorpion32]

@acejamal1

with respect brother have you researched the people you call a kafir because there is a serious repayment for those who openly slander ppl without proof have you actually seen what the average simple deobandi mirzai shia does be careful

[mo98183]

He says many good things Mashallah, however he makes excuses for those of who commit open kufr and makes "reconciliation" with those that celebrate the birthday of the Prophet (p), yet slanders those who do "suicide bombing" and imply they follow themselves only, without acknowledging that even on this issue there is significant differences of opinion. Yet we find there to be no differences of opinion on the issue of celebration of Prophet's (p) birthday and implementing "alwala wal bara".

[acejamal1]

Wow this guy calls himself a scholar he's munafiq Albani does not possess one Sanad for any of the teachers he claims are his teachers!

He claims to have studied fiqh yet he supports the Deobandi's and he is a student from there then he should know that "to doubt kufr is kufr itself"! He goes on to say they are schools of thought! go back and study your fiqh again fool There was no difference in the Aqeeda of the Aima Mujtahideen they only differed in fiqh! Wahabi deobandi mirzai shia all same