he is indeed quite in-tune at the min 7:10, for those of you who heard him out of tune, this is because he changed mode from Oshagh to Segah. and he actually hit the note D for a quick second which is a note past C of Mokhalef. Usually in Segah, you do not go to D , D is only used in Mokhalef but he likes to do it and truthfully I am amazed he is still capable of doing it. So No he is in tune alright, your ears are just not used to hearing that note that high. Shajarian never stops amazing me.
I would say he is still the best. I dont know of anyone who is even comparable, not even his own son. that one second is nothing compare to all his great works.
besyar ziba.bavar kardani nist in bashar!dorood e hezar bareh be aziz e del e honar doostan.merci,merci,merci.man yaghin daram ke farhang e Iran baz Shajarian khahad dasht,barha va barha,vali ne be in asooni!emrooz "be jahan zendeh az anam ke jahan zendeh az oost".dorood bar hame.
I don't agree with that, Ustad is in GRIEF in this video, and that is because of Ustad Mushkatyan. The more he grows older, the greater he gets, this performance have left me speechless and made me cry like a baby, who can Sing like that at 69 years old???? Young singers Can't ever sing like him, there would not be another Ustad again!!
thanks a lot for this wonderful, priceless piece of Art... God bless everybody,
he is indeed quite in-tune at the min 7:10, for those of you who heard him out of tune, this is because he changed mode from Oshagh to Segah. and he actually hit the note D for a quick second which is a note past C of Mokhalef. Usually in Segah, you do not go to D , D is only used in Mokhalef but he likes to do it and truthfully I am amazed he is still capable of doing it. So No he is in tune alright, your ears are just not used to hearing that note that high. Shajarian never stops amazing me.
sean7431 2 months ago
tabaraka lah :) a fan from morocco !
mayazusue 6 months ago
گفتم آهن دلی کنم چندی ندهم دل به هیچ دلبندی
خاصه ما را که در ازل بودهست با تو آمیزشی و پیوندی
به دلت کز دلت به درنکنم سختتر زین مخواه سوگندی
یک دم آخر حجاب یک سو نه تا برآساید آرزومندی
کاشکی خاک بودمی در راه تا مگر سایه بر من افکندی
چه کند بندهای که از دل و جان نکند خدمت خداوندی
سعدیا دور نیک نامی رفت نوبت عاشقیست یک چندی
samgulha 8 months ago
@bferd001 I totally agree with you. There is only one Ustad and always will be.
samgulha 1 year ago
He is not out of tune at all.
alpes222 1 year ago
I would say he is still the best. I dont know of anyone who is even comparable, not even his own son. that one second is nothing compare to all his great works.
bferd001 1 year ago
besyar ziba.bavar kardani nist in bashar!dorood e hezar bareh be aziz e del e honar doostan.merci,merci,merci.man yaghin daram ke farhang e Iran baz Shajarian khahad dasht,barha va barha,vali ne be in asooni!emrooz "be jahan zendeh az anam ke jahan zendeh az oost".dorood bar hame.
sholehflower 2 years ago
I don't agree with that, Ustad is in GRIEF in this video, and that is because of Ustad Mushkatyan. The more he grows older, the greater he gets, this performance have left me speechless and made me cry like a baby, who can Sing like that at 69 years old???? Young singers Can't ever sing like him, there would not be another Ustad again!!
thanks a lot for this wonderful, priceless piece of Art... God bless everybody,
samgulha 2 years ago
Yes, but that was really hard. His voice is now more bass than his youth time. He should have known better.
asemaany 2 years ago
wow yes he is out of tune...its saddening..
neemaz 2 years ago