Nightwish live in NYC - 10/18/07 - Slaying the Dreamer
Uploader Comments (TruculentBones)
Top Comments
-
Since when they were metal because of Tarja's voice? -.-' What a nonsense.
-
Out of all the old songs they are performing now, Anette is especially bad in this one and in Wishmaster. Plus the songs are changed. They sound so different now.
All Comments (67)
-
Woah!! I'm surprised to see this song!! :)
-
She has IMMENSE trouble with this song at certain parts......but I still like it. YAY ANETTE. Just don't attempt the high notes!!!!!!!!!
-
omfg, i think i just had a mental orgasm from the ammount of common sense in your comment.
-
to be fair, i think thats the poor quality of the video, not anettes voice... ??
-
haha, thats even a stupid argument! i'd say they are gothic symphonic metal, if we're being specific, but ImaginaryVoncroy is totally right, the voice doesnt make the genre - not to mention an operatic voice which isnt metal at all!!!
-
Sorry... I had a hard time filming shit because people kept knocking into me.
-
Dammit! You cut out the best part of the song!!!!
-
well i would say they are symphonic power metal or something like that xD
-
Yep... You're actually right, and I'm still sorry... Well, without the voice [I mean, if you just listen to the music], I'd still consider them metal, maybe not melodic metal, but a different kind... Something like power metal.
Oh goodness... I'm hoping it's the bad quality of audio on this thing that makes her sound so horrendous (spelling sucks, I know) in this... Was there anyone in that show that can say it didn't sound so painful with good quality?
00Rotem00 4 years ago
She sounds really bad in all the YouTube videos I've seen. I almost didn't go see them because I thought she was going to suck but she was really really good and now I like her.
Seriously - she doesn't suck. Maybe on Wishmaster, but everything else is really good.
TruculentBones 4 years ago
Even on this? I thought she killed the end... I mean, if you can't do a voice triller, esspecialy a long one, don't bother doing one at all.
00Rotem00 4 years ago
Her overall performance was really good. She has good stage presence and seems really warm. I went to the show expecting to hate her and by the end of the show I wanted to give her a hug.
It can't be easy to have to endure so many people comparing her to Tarja and calling her a hack all the time.
If you have the opportunity to go see them live, you really should. They were great.
TruculentBones 4 years ago
1-They are excellent
2-Her clothes have nothing to do with music
3-The entire band made the decision
4-Stop wasting your time commenting here if you don't like Anette. Go comment on Tarja's stuff
5-You really all act like babies...try and conduct yourself as true fans.If you don't like what they have done,fine it's your opinion but don't insult someone for no reasons...especially if you haven't seen them live yet.
Hellskinky 4 years ago 2
Touche.
TruculentBones 4 years ago