Haha man I have been searching for a quality list on youtube all day and this is the first one i actually like, like i'd give it a 86% out of 100. Not to be to much of a critic, but your missing guys like Bart Starr (7 NFl Championships), Otto Graham (10 straight championship games), and Kurt Warner (3 super bowl visits, one win, "Greatest Show on Turf"), but overall, good list
You can't use superbowls to say who's the best, Super Bowls are won by a team, plenty of QBs fail to win one(like Dan Marino) because the overall team wasn't strong enough.
1.Brett Farve 2.Fran Tarkenton 2. Dan Marino 4. Otto Graham 5. Johnny U 6. Payton Manning 7.Joe Montana 8.Warren Moon 9. John Elway 10. *Ken Stabler(* is for 'Stick-em')
I've rejected Bradshaw, Brady, Mcnabb, Young and Aikmen because their success had more to do with the rest of their teams.
You all make valid points, but are any of you old enough to have seen John Unitas play? Since most of you mention only those quaterbacks who made their marks pre 1970, I'm guessing none of you saw Unitas play. There were better arms (though not many) but no one lead a team like Unitas. And he called all of his own plays. Watch the next to the last play of the 1958 championship game vs the Giants. Pure guts. Pure leadership. Pure Unitas.
@brewersfan892 you have aaron rodgers, he's just as good
chrisreynaud1 2 weeks ago
brees
chrisreynaud1 2 weeks ago
where the hell is drew breed
chrisreynaud1 2 weeks ago
Haha man I have been searching for a quality list on youtube all day and this is the first one i actually like, like i'd give it a 86% out of 100. Not to be to much of a critic, but your missing guys like Bart Starr (7 NFl Championships), Otto Graham (10 straight championship games), and Kurt Warner (3 super bowl visits, one win, "Greatest Show on Turf"), but overall, good list
TSASports12 2 weeks ago
@lazyidiotofthemonth you dnt remeber the perfect season?
mosesj92 2 months ago
Brady shouldnt be there
25Thebeastmode 2 months ago
You can't use superbowls to say who's the best, Super Bowls are won by a team, plenty of QBs fail to win one(like Dan Marino) because the overall team wasn't strong enough.
1.Brett Farve 2.Fran Tarkenton 2. Dan Marino 4. Otto Graham 5. Johnny U 6. Payton Manning 7.Joe Montana 8.Warren Moon 9. John Elway 10. *Ken Stabler(* is for 'Stick-em')
I've rejected Bradshaw, Brady, Mcnabb, Young and Aikmen because their success had more to do with the rest of their teams.
lazyidiotofthemonth 2 months ago
Close..but no. Here are the top 15 of all time in order....TAKE NOTE....
1. Montana. 2. Manning. 3. Unitas. 4. Favre. 5. Elway 6. Brady 7. Marino 8. Young 9. Tarkenton 10. Bradshaw 11. Brees 12. Staubach 13. Namath 14. Aikman 15. Warner. Honorable mention: Moon, Fouts.
XYGAGuy 4 months ago
You all make valid points, but are any of you old enough to have seen John Unitas play? Since most of you mention only those quaterbacks who made their marks pre 1970, I'm guessing none of you saw Unitas play. There were better arms (though not many) but no one lead a team like Unitas. And he called all of his own plays. Watch the next to the last play of the 1958 championship game vs the Giants. Pure guts. Pure leadership. Pure Unitas.
cawdorglamis 5 months ago
@ ayolaw92 This list is a really good one! Besides, it's his opinion.
brewersfan892 7 months ago