Seventeen - Sophie-May Metcalfe
Uploader Comments (sophiemaymetcalfe)
Top Comments
-
Sounds great soph :)
Ps. errh "why put up songs of you only expect positivity?" i have a question.. Why comment if your only going to be negitive?
Video Responses
All Comments (37)
-
loved it :D amazing song!
-
im here to appreciate good music. i subscribed your voice is beautiful.
-
Hey Sophie I honestly think this is awesome!
All the negative tools commenting are either failures as musicians and are jealous they cannot write songs, or they have no musical knowledge what so ever!
keep up the good work! ;)
-
Yes, I put this song under one of my favorite playlists... I love it.
-
that one dislike is justin bieber o_O
-
@sophiemaymetcalfe hey thank you! Just wondering, which points did you agree with?
-
Sophe this is amazing is this really your first original!!! Masteronlines just jealous cos he/she sounds like fingernails on a chalk board :-P.
-
like
-
@mastersonline13 Dude, there is the slightest bit of resemblance at the beginning of the piece, give it a rest. If the music of one musician resembles another musician’s music it generally means that person has a high regard for the piece, even if they don’t mean to show it. Writing a piece of music is something not many people can truly master and I applaud this girl for giving it a shot and succeeding.
Here's some more things you should look at: 1. Write original guitar parts that aren't taken from 'Under the Bridge' by the Chilli Peppers 2. Don't write singing parts that copy the guitar line 3. Don't expect fans from X Factor to swallow whatever you do, especially poorly written 'originals'. Just my opinion. But you've definitely ripped off Under the Bridge. I liked you on X Factor, and your covers, and thats probably where you should stay??? We have some fantastic covers bars in Melbourne
mastersonline13 3 months ago
@mastersonline13 Hi, thanks for the feedback. Whilst I appreciate it, I think some of your comments were a bit negative. I went & checked out your profile.. seems you only joined youtube yesterday & you haven't done anything but comment on my video.. Who are you? I can see that there is one second of the guitar that sounds similar to 'Under the Bridge', however this can be changed & the rest of the song has a completely different chord progression and can stand on it's own without this.
sophiemaymetcalfe 3 months ago 20
Hey Sophie I'm not being an ass here cause this song is really good as a whole there a just a couple things I think you should look at (only my opinion remember). I think you should have a ~2sec pause between "you'll make it through" & the start of the chorus (start chorus ~2:10 instead of 2:08). I would prefer the chorus without the echo (just seems a little too strong imo), and I think you should only repeat it twice (i.e. omit 2nd & 3rd repeat @2:23->2:52 but keep 1st & 4th repeats).
mcxandio 3 months ago
@mcxandio but yeah the lyrics and instruments and singing are all really good it's just those small couple of things to change and it'll be great!
mcxandio 3 months ago
@mcxandio Thanks alot - your feedback is much appreciated, and I agree with a couple of your points!
sophiemaymetcalfe 3 months ago
@mcxandio hey there, thankyou for the feedback! as said above in the info - the song isn't completed - it's still a work in progress, but just wanted to upload it so people could get a taste of what I have been doing :). Thanks for the tips/thoughts! x
sophiemaymetcalfe 3 months ago