Emmy Destinn - D'amor Sull'ali - Il Trovatore - Verdi
Loading...
6,249
Loading...
Uploader Comments (MrCafiero)
see all
All Comments (25)
-
simply priceless
-
Just breathtaking. Thank you so much.
-
Can you imagine how great this performance would be if they didn't have to speed up the tempo to accommodate the vinyl? It would be the exemplar, period.
-
It's alway's a thrill/to hear a soprano/with voice big as the hills/trip off her tonque/runs,roulades,and trills!
-
Sensational! TY.
-
Brava!
-
Obrovský talent,nádherná žena...stále nedoceněná...
-
one of the best! thanks.
M.
Loading...
Would you agree Chaliapin was naturally gifted at birth?
Some folks just have that fortunate gift, others try so
hard.
I do respect and thank you for your experienced
comments.
schlusnus 2 years ago
Of course all the greats were gifted. I am just saying that talent can take you far, but the same talent with a limited technique cannot do what the same talent with a great technique can do. I believe there are still very talented and gifted people, but they severely lack technique. The approach that is taught in the universities today is severely limited. You should read, "The End of the Great Big American Voice" from the NY Times.
MrCafiero 2 years ago
Totally agree....you either have it or you don't, surely
thats why there's the difference..no amount of training
can make an average voice into a ..Schipa,Gigli, etc.
Look at Eliz: Schumann or Lotte yes 6 yrs of learning
before on stage, they were gifted from birth. That seperates the new voices from the old.Their Greats.!
schlusnus 2 years ago
That is not the only reason why there is a difference. The teaching also has to be there and today it isn't. We have not changed physiologically and there are very talented people with very bad technique.
MrCafiero 2 years ago
@schlusnus
There are plenty of wonderful talents who had poor
technique and either never made it or had short careers.
65attila 1 year ago
@65attila That is right and it should not be that way. Too many fake teachers out there.
MrCafiero 1 year ago