MN GOP Redistricting Chair Argues With Witness

Minnesota Republicans have taken heat from the public indicating more discussion about their redistricting plan is really desired. The conversations between Redistricting committee chair Sarah Anderson and testifiers have been terse. During the only House hearing held on the legislative redistricting plan since it was released, Representative Anderson interrupted non-partisan testimony from Mankato City Manager Tom Hedges when he used the word "gerrymander" to describe one of the lines in the Republican map. She objected to the use of the word and interrupted him twice more and then dismissed him before he could finish his testimony. Representative Melissa Hortman (DFL) then asked Anderson "Could we allow the witnesses to just share their thoughts and not argue with them as they present it?" Applause then broke out in the hearing room to which Anderson banged her gavel and told the public "you are out of order. I will not have you outbursting like that at all." Hortman went on to ask "Typically when a member presents their bill, they sit at the testifying table. And typically what occurs is when a witness testifies on the members bill, then the members of the committee will ask questions and the witness may respond and the author of the bill may respond. But typically the author of the bill does not sit in the chairmanship and interrupt witnesses who are testifying with questions, comments and concerns about the members bill. And I think that little bit of separation maybe, would make the process flow a little smoother. I just offer as a constructive suggestion that there are a lot of people who have things to say and there's two ways we could do it. One, we could just listen and then we can ask questions at the end so we can get through as many people as possible or the member who is presenting the bill could go to the testifying table to provide some distance between the testifiers and the author of the bill. Anderson: Well I appreciate that feedback Representative Hortman. But I've seen it done many different ways. Some chairs have decided to stay at the table and some have gone up to the testifier table. So it's done both ways. And this is the way I prefer to do it. Representative Karen Clark (DFL) asked Anderson to "show mutual respect". "We have people who have come a long distance. If you could, please adopt an attitude of lets listen to the witnesses first and then the kind of correction you just wanted to make, go ahead and do it afterwards. I feel I really didn't get to hear the end of what the concern was of that particular witness. So I'm hoping for the subsequent witnesses we can actually hear them out and if you want to make sure that they understand something about the process you don't think they understand that would be OK. But we didn't really get to hear the whole concern. ... Let's just be a little more calm and mutually respectful. Anderson " I would like the respect on this level as well. When people say that this plan is 'gerrymandered', I take great offense to that. This plan is a good plan that is fair to the entire state of Minnesota and when someone accuses me and this committee of putting together a gerrymandered plan I , I find that offensive."

Category:

News & Politics

Tags:

• sarah anderson
• melissa hortman
• karen clark
• redistricting

[b2tama]

Haha what a scumbag! How can she defend the plan? It is very obviously a gerrymandered plan! It's always a gerrymandered plan no matter which party is in charge!

[gringojohn2]

Don't question that chair lady er else!

[SlobbyHill]

@justonefirefly1 True class. Thank you for showing the prime example of a Democrat. Might I suggest Google Chrome? It has spell check.

[justonefirefly1]

tHE LAST TIME i BELIEVED A FUCKING REPUBLICUNT WAS WHEN bUSH SAID THAT HE WAS GOING TO GIT BIN LADEN AND THEN DECLARED WAR ON IRAQ WHEN THE FUCKING 9/11 HIJACKERS WERE FROM SAUDI ARABIA

FUCK YOU MURDERING FUCKING REPUBLICUNTS IT TOOK A DEMOCRAT TO GIT BIN LADEN AND WITH FAR LESS THAN A 3 TRILLION DOLLAR WAR FUCK ING SLUT REPUBLICUNT WHORES FUCK YOUR FUCKING MOTHERS WHO GAVE BIRTH TO SUCH ANTI AMERICAN FUCKING WHORES

[TheShahrazad1]

I find this Chair to be an exemplar of the GOP: domineering, self-righteous & dismissive.

[SunRunnerNY]

WOW! just wow....

[MrRichardKranium]

They are not out of order they are right, your just a narcissistic cunt with a gavel.

[paddedshell]

Fuuuuuuuuuuck, what a witch... I'm totally spooked!

[16Sammie]

This is what happens when you don't vote. Stand up and be counted!

[rosavanwinkle]

He looks nervous. Why so serious, MR HANSH?