Top Comments
All Comments (595)
-
@andreasegde She is from my town Barnsley, England?
-
This is my fav version of wild mountain thyme ... Also, the lead singer of the Silencers is the double of a guy that used to drive the buses!!
-
God, isn't she beautiful.
-
Simply grand video! The sofa on the truck was so effective. Beautiful backdrop for a beautiful song
-
I first heard this in the mid-90's and it immediately hit me with its class. I play it over to reflect on those times. Great recording.
-
@timeforthebigsleep & (part) Scot ! :D
-
Please God no! I just think poor old Tannahill deserves a wee bit of credit is all. And anyway, he would have been a "guid proddy man" too, just like his lofty contemporary, Rab Burns or McPeake himself, for that matter! So no sectarian difference, and I'm no Rep' anyway.
If you were to describe this as a McPeake reworking/ arrangement/ adaptation of Tannahill, I'd be fine with that. But not that he "wrote" the song, which old Francie never claimed anyway!
-
@DonegalRaymie201 I agree. l never knew about the court case. It is ridiculous that the McPeake family tried to claim royalties, it is part of the folk tradition.
Honestly, when l saw your claim, l assumed it was rooted in sectarian bias that permeates anything even vaguely related to Northern Ireland.
-
Yes, it is a folk song, so they should never have been trying to claim royalties in the 1st place, which may well have angered the Judge, especially when the defence produced an old edition of Tannahill's work!
And I'm not blaming old Francie McPeake, as I said, he claimed he learned it from his uncle, but his family's opportunism.
Weird thing is, Tannahill, being "lang deid", meant that the original was out of copywright, so it wouldn't have cost a bean to credit him!
-
@DonegalRaymie201 shocked by the plagiarism claim even by a judge. I know this sounds really repetitive and simplistic--but its a folk song! :)
As is my understanding, the poem itself was published posthumously in 1821. l know that there are Scottish folk arrangements, which were primitive but nevertheless influenced McPeake.
I don't believe that McPeake wanted to pass it off as his own at all, the Tannahill poem is well known in Scotland and
Ulster. His family's motives were self serving



Makes you proud to be Scottish!
timeforthebigsleep 5 months ago 12
I keep coming "home" to this video and whenever I feel a bit down it provides an emotional lift to get me through the night.....keep it here, please.
Vanfan8 7 months ago 3