Part 1 - What is Sound?
Loading...
Link to this comment:
Uploader Comments (CraigTube)
All Comments (83)
-
the vibration is there but the interpretation is lost, much like asking do waves leave marks on a beach if you aren't there to see them....
-
My take on "If a tree falls does anyone here it " is a metaphysical one, If not observed by an aware being ,it reacts differently to our perceived concepts of our reality. Therefore if an aware being with a totally different concept of reality would view it completely different.If no aware being observes it then it just "IS"
-
The existence of sound is a dependent related phenomena, that being it requires something that causes sound and an observer with a hearing capacity to receive it. Everything is dependent related. You can't have one without the other.
-
If sound is the interpretation of vibrations or noise then the questions answer is still no, or more precisely the question is invalid.
The question asks if a tree falls in the forest does it make a sound?
If sound is the act of hearing or perceiving vibrating air as sound then trees can't make sound, only noise.
5:24Home Brew Wednesday #12 - junk Drawersby CraigTube2,575 views
- 16:15Craig's Kitchen - Poutineby CraigTube4,502 views
- 6:44Home Brew Wednesday #11 - My Steinby CraigTube3,227 views
- 8:27Home Brew Review plus Bloopersby CraigTube4,568 views
- 4:38Craig Live Television Performance - 1993by CraigTube8,933 views
- 2:30Sound, Energy, and Wave Motion (clip)by phoenixfilmandvideo16,894 views
- 2:44What Sound Looks Likeby diggabyte230,884 views
- 10:42pt 5 - Coopers Beer Kit TASTE TEST!!! Final in ...by TakeSomeAdvice5,638 views
- 2:09The physics of soundby jupiter893,098 views
- 10:12Walt Disney - Toot, Whistle, Plunk And Boom - ...by lpmangas186,185 views
- 2:39Igor Teaches Sound Wavesby ajsianez942 views
- 6:51It's Not Our Eyes That See,It Is Our Brainby harunyahyacom447 views
- 25:26Obama UFO Disclosure Plansby CraigTube8,648 views
- 5:03Science of Soundby NASAconnect265,936 views
- 10:18Sound Waves and their Sources (1933)by timegrinder97,091 views
- 2:19If A Tree Falls In The Forest....by cipher6191,059 views
- 0:51The Ear: the Organ of Hearingby dizzo95193,742 views
- 9:43CraigTalk - What happens when you die?by CraigTube8,424 views
- 15:18Easy Home Brewing with a Cooper's Micro Brew Kitby CraigTube109,166 views
God I love your voice man!! Whenever I drink a beer I always check out one of your videos. I cant put my finger on it... You have a soothing, intelligent, boomerang way about the way you speak. Its awesome.
mushroomhill 5 months ago
@mushroomhill Wow, thanks! :)
CraigTube 5 months ago
I don't think sound is dependent on the receiver. I'm pretty sure "sound" is the waves through a medium.
tophu1021 5 months ago
@tophu1021 Let's put it this way... If there was no life on earth, then there would be nobody to decide that waves produce sound. They are just waves and are meaningless unless someone "hears" them and decides that there is sound. Waves are just waves. Sound is our interpretation or sensation produced by those waves.
CraigTube 5 months ago
If you make up a chord that doesn't exist, and play it can you hear that non existing chord or can you not hear it?
diamondyeqy 8 months ago
@diamondyeqy The question is can you make up a chord? You can blend several random note together and call it a chord, but it probably won't sound good, because music is based on math. However, you would still hear it.
CraigTube 8 months ago