Matthew Bellamy - Exogenesis Symphony (3)
Top Comments
All Comments (41)
-
Yes - when people say Matt composed this piece, they're referring to the predominant orchestral elements. The drums and bass also play a part in this, and their parts were composed and played by Dom and Chris. It's a band effort.
-
@rollercoasterchess Yes, I agree, but are you saying now that Bellamy only partly wrote this symphony and that others wrote the rest? Like some kind of composition collective? If that is the case you proved your point.
-
I see where you're coming from, but there's a difference. If Bach composes a piece and hands it to the orchestra, Bach is the composer, the orchestra are the performers. We credit Bach for the genius. But this is like giving Bach all the credit even though the string parts were written by an entirely different person. Dom and Chris aren't just "performers" here, they played a significant part in the composition of this piece.
-
@bartje11 Despite all this we share our common love for music! Happy New Year. Cheers!!
-
@bartje11 Matthew Bellamy is a classically trained musician, he knows his composers, he writes his music on paper and scores it. It would be interesting to hear what he would have to say about this...... I would love to hear it.
-
@rollercoasterchess Yes, I am a composer and write everything, every note myself. The people who perform it are playing MY notes and not theirs. And furthermore they will get the usual credit as performers. I think our disagreement comes from the fact that I look at it from the composers perspective and you from the groups point of view. I know that the bass player, drummer etc, etc will come up with their own ideas and licks, which can make or break a piece.
-
Once again, it's just Muse. It's not a big leap from "Matthew Bellamy and Muse" to "Matt and some dudes". They're practically the same. Furthermore, what you're doing is crediting one composer despite the work having compositional contributions from multiple people. If you were a composer, you would appreciate the piece in its entirety, and all parties involved. Point is, you give Matt way more attention than is needed - all Dom and Chris get is a wikipedia excerpt.
-
@bartje11 And I start the info with "the genius of Matthew Bellamy and Muse" Not good enough for you? Why can't I give my respect as a composer to another composer?
-
When a song is written by Paul McCartney, it means he wrote the lyrics. It doesn't mean he gave George and Ringo a bunch of sheet music. From a musical standpoint, it's still a band effort. Queen is another example - Freddie was their main lyricist, he "wrote" most of their songs, it doesn't mean he wrote the guitar solos for Brian, or the drum fills for Roger.
And yeah, you show them in the video, but I direct you to the title of the video and the comment war I replied to.
-
@rollercoasterchess Of course I know that, but I mention Muse in the video, I show them don't I? But are you telling me that Matthew Bellamy didn't write the music? That;s why we have songs written by Paul McCartney and John Lennon, or George Harrisson, or one or two Ringo Starr and NOT the Beatles. Is the same!
This band (particularly this man) is so incredible. Exogenesis can move me to tears, something that no other contemporary musician or artist has been able to do for me. That's power.
Lead on, Muse.
Commentator25 10 months ago 11
hes great and the bands awesome and thanks for all the info in description :)
Joexd777 1 year ago 6