@factofile I don't think that this discussion is important at this moment in time as we see the middle east rising...we should demonstrate to the world as being one muslims first......and staying on the same point.. everyone has their own experience and I certainly am a lucky one in that context.
And to say that this is shirk....they never say to worship them...it is from Allah that everything is gifted....only a pious person can maybe convince you which I am not....
@mokhan247 I can't argue with you on that because this is a subject for scholars and on which no one has similar opinion and thats why we have sects. So you can continue to be ashamed on that.....but do tell me this that you have never dreamt where a passed away relative have hinted of passed a message...if not then you have not experienced anything. my your heart open up and you see the spiritual side of life too. And to say that this is shirk....
@factofile Well let's see, this is the place where people come from various places in Pakistan and they seek assistance from a dead guy. Am I ashamed that such shirk-based activity takes place in my village? Yes. Am I ashamed of my roots. i.e. the locality of where I am from? No.
@mokhan247 so I still don't understand why you said that 'I am ashamed to say that this place is in our village in Pakistan.' if that was intended to be funny then I apologize.
subhan allah
riamuhni 3 weeks ago
@factofile
this is what i thought would happen. thanks
mokhan247 11 months ago
@factofile I don't think that this discussion is important at this moment in time as we see the middle east rising...we should demonstrate to the world as being one muslims first......and staying on the same point.. everyone has their own experience and I certainly am a lucky one in that context.
factofile 11 months ago
@mokhan247 I know it VERY WELL...and I don't want to get into any argument over it...and as I said may Allah open your heart so that you may see....
factofile 11 months ago
@factofile
Then you don't know the meaning of Shirk and neither do you know the meaning of Tawheed.
mokhan247 11 months ago
And to say that this is shirk....they never say to worship them...it is from Allah that everything is gifted....only a pious person can maybe convince you which I am not....
factofile 1 year ago
@mokhan247 I can't argue with you on that because this is a subject for scholars and on which no one has similar opinion and thats why we have sects. So you can continue to be ashamed on that.....but do tell me this that you have never dreamt where a passed away relative have hinted of passed a message...if not then you have not experienced anything. my your heart open up and you see the spiritual side of life too. And to say that this is shirk....
factofile 1 year ago
@factofile Well let's see, this is the place where people come from various places in Pakistan and they seek assistance from a dead guy. Am I ashamed that such shirk-based activity takes place in my village? Yes. Am I ashamed of my roots. i.e. the locality of where I am from? No.
mokhan247 1 year ago
@mokhan247 so I still don't understand why you said that 'I am ashamed to say that this place is in our village in Pakistan.' if that was intended to be funny then I apologize.
factofile 1 year ago
@factofile
If I was ashamed of my roots, why would I make it apparent that the place in the video is in the locality of where I am from?
mokhan247 1 year ago