養神館合気道、aikido Inoue sensei teaching mysterious waza

wow! Nyaaaa

Category:

Sports

Tags:

• aikido
• yoshinkan

[JiggyHo]

I think I just got this. Every impact is when uke's feet are close together ... exactly when he has no leg behind to push with. That's the point of 'timing', if I understand right. Very clever. NOT the bullshit it looks like.

[ilostabuttonhole]

coordination, timing, momumentum and YEARS of training. nothing mysterious about it...

[321SpikE]

I'm not sure if this works against a kick in the nuts

[panheaddan1]

as a student of aikido , and i dont speak japanes , i think what sensei is saying is : the transference of energy is in the timing.

[HomunculusProject]

@JiggyHo Well, for demonstration purposes I guess some uke fall a bit dramatically.

[HomunculusProject]

@Derukugi2 Then, instead of just claiming that it is bullshit with practically no knowledge or experience at all:

Why not try it out instead?

I wanna see you running into a stable guy and not falling over standing on one leg during contact.

[Derukugi2]

@HomunculusProject

I did not say "it works", and I am not arguing.

I simply referred to what the instructor in the video is saying. That does not mean I believe one iota of it.

[HomunculusProject]

@Derukugi2 So in summary: it works, it teaches timing, reading movement and posture of the attacker, stabilizing yourself, etc

And it's bullshit.

Care to back up actual arguments?

[Derukugi2]

@HomunculusProject

Listen to the tape. He is talking about that. If you don´t speak Japanese, sorry I don´t have time to babysit you.

In any case, as I said, this is where Aikido meets Bullshido.

[HomunculusProject]

@Derukugi2 WHEN do they connect? WHAT timing? Tip: Look at the feet.

He turns the shoulder inwards so stabilize the shoulders.

I did this once and I didn't know that I should use that break fall. So I fell "normally" and it blew my air out.

This works perfectly fine, as long as your uke isn't a weakling with no strength in his arms.

[Derukugi2]

@HomunculusProject

I open my eyes, and I am listening. He says it is about timing about turning your sholder in. I say it is about a compliant uke who throws himself backward.

This where Aikido weirs off into bullshido.

[HomunculusProject]

@Derukugi2 Not if you actually open your eyes. Of all aikido-moves that look strange, this one is fairly easy to understand.