Uploaded by iambaichi on Jul 31, 2008
韓國白飯先生 警告日本 領土糾紛-獨島(竹島)
Dokdo : S.Korea Territory
Diaoyudao : China Territory
I think that the opinion of Japanese government has some logical problems. First, let's think about the fundamental difference on the opinion about Dokdo between Korea and Japan According to the Korea's opinion, Silla occupied Ulying-island at A.D.512 and got the sovereign authority on Dokdo. And after that, Dokdo has been belonged to Korea till nowadays. However, we cannot find any record that shows the occupation of Dokdo and Ulying-island but only the record about operations like private fishing.
Moreover, what Japanese Government insists goes against the doctrine of succession of government and the doctrine of estoppel. I am going to deal with the doctrine of estoppel in the second question and now, i am going to concentrate more on the doctrine of succession of government. The International law defines the doctrine of succession of government as follows. "If a new party gets the power or establishes a constitution in a similar situation of the territory and population as before, it is just alternation of the government in other word; it is nothing more than a succession of government.
After the Second World War, German and Italy government had to compensate for damage to the related nations with the same reason in other word, the identity of nation was maintained followed the doctrine of succession of government. This doctrine is not limited just in the responsibility of compensation. The succession of government is also adapted to what the former government insisted on territory. It is natural and reasonable to follow this doctrine because the insistence on territory is a sensitive topic that can break the world peace and it also has an improtant foundation for a national existence.
Japan has been changed from Edo Bakufu to the Japan Empire with Meiji government and to Japan in nowadays. It is conformed to the general order succession of government. However, Japanese government didn't declare that they occupied Dokdo before, and they also recognized Dokdo as a territory of Korea as I stated above. The diplomatic document from Edo Bakufu to Jeseon about the prohibition license to permit crossing the sea can prove this. Considering this circumstance, Meiji government which successes the Edo Bakufu should follow this fact.
And actually, the magistrate of Sinema-ken in Meiji government gave an official order about the position of Dokdo like this through a reply to Taejeong in March 21 in 1877, "We, Japan, has no relation with Ulying and another one island. We should remember it. "It shows that Japanese government recognized no territorial relationship between Japan and Dokdo and they also don't have any right or jurisdiction about Dokdo. It is reasonable management that follows the succession of Edo Bakufu. However, in 1905, Japan suddenly insisted that Dokdo is an island that is not belongs to any countries. It is an act that violates not only the doctrine of succession of government and also the doctrine of estoppel. With this reason, we can find that the insistence of Japan has lots of problems.
独島は韓国の固有の領土である。
独島は歴史的であり、地理的に韓国の領土だが、日本は無理押しの主張をしている。
独島は歴史的、地理的に韓国の領土だが、話にならない主張をしている。
また、日本はあの主張を世界に知らせて、世界の地図に独島を日本の領土で表記し、韓国 の東海を日本海で表記している。
1。独島、西紀512年から韓国の領土。
2.フランスの地理学者のダンビルの「朝鮮王国全図」で独島を韓国の領土で表紙
3.日本の古文献と日本の古地図で独島を韓国の領土で記録。
4.17世紀末、日本政府は独島、ウルン島を韓国の領土で再確認
5.19世紀、日本明治政府の公文書で独島、ウルン島を韓国の領土で認め。
6.日本内務省は独島、ウルン島を韓国の領土で再確認。
7.日本の最高国家機関の太政官は独島、ウルン島を韓国の領土で決定
8.19世紀末、大韓帝国政府は独島、ウルン島を韓国の領土で的確に表紙。
9.1900年大韓帝国の勅令第42号で独島を韓国の領土で世界へ公表
10.日本は1950年独島を強制編入
11.連合国、1946年1月に独島を韓国に変換する軍令を発表。
12.連合国の「旧日本の領土処理に関する合意書」、"独島は韓国の領土であり"と規 定
13.連合国、サンフランシスコ'対日本強化江華条約'で独島を抜き。
14.国連軍、独島を韓国の領土に含め。
-
20 likes, 15 dislikes
1:09
Robot Taekwon V vs. Japanese Stereotypes Robot(Protect Dokdo)by iambaichi42,177 views
0:44
Dokdo is Korean territory for no doubtby iambaichi3,133 views
2:47
Dokdo is Korean! 독도는 한국섬이다! 独島は韓国の領土だby bundangbear135,475 views
4:51
Dokdo(독도는 生命!) - Cho Young Pil(조용필趙容弼) The Life of Koreansby iambaichi7,222 views
5:45
Dokdo is Korean territoryby nakseo5,135 views
0:40
Infinity challenge - dokdo songby beerkim8,223 views
2:37
백반형님 6.2 지방선거 호소영상 .aviby couragekim11,860 views
4:55
Dokdo in The East sea of Koreaby Wonku07142,144 views
2:45
Japan is lying! We know the truth about Dokdoby docukimpd44,334 views
2:01
Welcome to Dokdo Koreaby ohyunho3,100 views
2:54
(독도는한국땅)Dokdo island is certainly belong to KOREAby kojongkeun14,621 views
0:55
竹島、韓国の大嘘by tomba2008347,801 views
3:26
Korean Dokdo (Takeshima, Wrong known term in Japan), Japanese 日本語 Subtitles includedby schubaka20,124 views
6:59
朝鮮人は目をそらすな!!독도 Dokdo 는 우리의 땅이다by ipod0407132,525 views
1:45
To Dokdo from Korea and from Japanby Dokdolians20,256 views
8:02
Korean Territory, Dokdo (english) part.1by ryuanee18,612 views
2:11
海外:2008/8/1 サイバースペースで韓日バトル、韓国大勝利(wby Internationalnera2,614 views
1:21
Japonlar'dan İstiklal Marşıby dadasim8,297 views
3:18
To Polisharabia: Why Dokdo IS Korean! 독도는 한국섬이다! 独島は韓国の領土だby bundangbear9,270 views
- Loading more suggestions...
hahha puto coreano !
yellowpokerman 5 months ago
@oregamienainokasugu ㅗ
lsilverstar 5 months ago
ㅋㅋㅋ 일본 잠기고 있당 ㅋㅋㅋ
FallenLightx 6 months ago
LOL dude I'm Korean and the on going Dokdo issue gets me all pissed off but this video was classic. This dude needs to lay off eating too much red meat, damn.
MASTERNCS 9 months ago 2
Japan never teach their past crimes to their student for making justification with their honor.
schubaka 1 year ago
@oregamienainokasugu저질.......
chase162636 1 year ago
ハンサムねw
hawaiikai2 1 year ago
우리들 열등 한국 원숭이는 일본인의 노예입니다. Dokdo는 일본의 영토입니다
oregamienainokasugu 1 year ago
당신은 입로보트 태권 C 니까?
5k4e2n9 1 year ago
당신은 통일 교회입니까? 창가학회입니까?
그렇지 않으면 섭리입니까?
5k4e2n9 1 year ago