Diana Degarmo - I Believe (encore)

Diana sings i believe on results night

Category:

Music

Tags:

• American
• Idol

[JennasMusic76]

I loved this as well but there was something magical about fantasias/

[Terryhelms76]

she was so much better then Fantasia!!!!!!!!!!!!

[MsJohnson016]

I watched the entire season and yes Diana sounds okay. She has a nice voice. Her last note was awesome! However, as I thought then, and still today, felt she was way out of her league singing against Fantasia. Heck, by the time it was down to the final four it was clear Fantasia was gonna win. Her performances were stellar!! She had completed the race while the other contestants were competing for runner up.

[shell19027]

So wow...here we are still playing and talking about the 2 performances. What I find that is most interesting is the comments that Fantasia's blessing and skills were inferior to Diana's. What planet were/are you people on??? Fantasia was absolutely FANTASTIC throughout her ENTIRE time. With each performance, they BOTH got better. But, clearly Diana's coach did not arrange her performances correctly, which is what added to the lack of experience, thereby her losing. But, she is making music now.

[draimanfan1984]

If American Idol would have remained a talent competition like it should have, Diana would have beat Fantasia hands down. Fantasia only won and got the votes because people felt sorry for her. Diana had the better and stronger voice by far.

[rosenbergbenadretti]

I'd take this anytime over Donald The Duck

[MOZ1175]

Always wanted to say this and now I am gonna, That little girl (because that what she was when this aired) sang the living shit out of this song. Physically drained herself, emotionally put every drop of her heart in that performance! Hells YEAH!!! I am still waiting for her to come back and show us what she is about today. Fantasia, step aside, check yourself into Betty Ford for a minute. Diana we are waiting!

[MOZ1175]

Diana should have won! Love her!!!

[LoneAlphaMaleWolf]

@NOVAseminole Completely agree. Got nothing against Fantasia, but I honestly can't see why she won.

[LoneAlphaMaleWolf]

In my opinion Diana was naturally much more talented than Fantasia. I mean wtf... was I the only one who saw that her voice was pure and clear as a diamond's, while Fantasia sounded like she was singing through a mouthful of oatmeal? Fantasia was a little less pitchier, sure, but it's only because she was older and had far more time to practice. Diana should've won.

[kcamowje]

Diana did good with this, she sounded good but Fantasia blew it out the water when she sung it, Fantasia sung it like Tamyra wrote it just for her