American Idol Live! - Carly (Bring Me to Life)

Carly Smithson singing "Bring Me to Life" by Evanescence.

**For higher quality add "&fmt=18" to the end of the URL**

American Idol Live!
San Diego ipayOne Center
July 02, 2008

Category:

Music

Tags:

• american
• idol
• live
• carly
• smithson
• bring
• me
• to
• life
• evanescence
• san
• diego
• ipayone

[wcbombers21]

SHE FUCKING SUCKS!!! I CAN HEAR AMY LEE SCREAMING (SHUT THE FUCK UP BITCH!!!)

[bvbbmthbfmv]

no one is like Amy Lee.

Amy Lee have the best voice of the world

[gothicashoker]

ohh, im carly and ive never heard of evanescence before i joined we are the fallen. bullshit

[septemberschannel]

@TheSidneycrosbey87 i guess nobody liked it:o

[mileygirl08]

she sounds pretty good

[iza1122331]

esta vieja que por dios no la canta tan bien como evanescence

[maytrinity]

We don't need to depreciate Carly to adore Amy. Both of them sing very well. Let they do what they love without comparing them! It's so childish!

[TheSidneycrosbey87]

I think she's good! Thumbs up if you liked it =)

[rockeriitahtellez]

she pretends to be like amy

dress like amy lee

she wants to sing like amy lee

but she never will be like amy lee

[Smickyla]

I hate Carly with an intense burning passion, but I don't think Amy would be all pissed at her. Amy's better than that, she's too good for that kind of stuff.

[aaronbenvenuti14]

how the hell is she trying to be amy lee? this was an entire year before she was even part of we are the fallen.... she wanted to do a rock song and this is the closest thing to rock they'd let her do.... i love evanescence always have and always will but you can say she is trying to be amy lee, amy would never do those vocal runs and personally i think she rocked it!