Eldred Marshall - Beethoven Sonata no. 19 in g minor
Top Comments
All Comments (17)
-
@emodomo Yes there are lots of discrepancies in the second movement. But I certainly cant deny that this performance is very musical. I enjoyed the first movement very much! :-)
-
amazing performance!!!
-
I've got the sheet music too and I DON'T hear any mistakes! open your ears, gee!
-
so "songs" are only short musical compositions with words/music? if you have someone singing for 10 minutes, would you still characterize it as a "song"? musicology 101: a "song" is a musical composition WITH WORDS - it has nothing to do with length. any real musician will tell you that critics are useless, and those who criticize yet not know the "technicalities" are laughable. learn more music, get the score, and learn something from this wonderful performance.
-
look. a song is a short musical composition of words and/or music. this sonata falls under that category. i don't think i need to know the technicality of this piece to judge that there were mistakes made. and though i'm not the next beethoven, i do participate in concerts.
-
if you're calling this two-movement sonata a "song" then you're probably not qualified to criticize him...
-
i'm not hating on him. i have the sheet music and i played the andante part of this song and i can hear many mistakes.
-
Beautiful rendition. THANK YOU.
-
Woow! :)
-
Amazingg
great... I love this piece.. very well played
sargentobarrios 3 years ago 7
very nice
crazysword987 3 years ago 4