Disproving Islam by Embryology - Dr William Champbell

How is the feotal development in Quran versus Biology? Sura 23:13-14

Category:

Education

Tags:

• embryology
• bones and flesh
• Sura 23:13-14

[yahmana]

@yougonasorry during the enlightenment period most arabs were muslims. scientists of the enlightement period combined science & faith together ( it wasn't two different things). I'll give you an example: greeks believed that it was wrong to experiment on animals, Muslims knew god didn't prohibit it & taught the greeks that it wasn't wrong to do experiments on animals & that has helped science a lot because without experimentation science wouldn't have advanced thus far

[yahmana]

@yougonasorry see this video about Muslim stealing knowledge from Greeks:

watch?v=m5ADiHsGoQo

[yahmana]

@yougonasorry passing knowledge from mouth to mouth is prone to be forgotten or even corrupted unless its written down. as I said not many people knew how to write (only about 16 people knew). Mohammad barely had anytime to busy himself learning medicine & science from the greeks, he spent most of his time worshiping god & delivering the message. again there is no historically proof that greeks passed any knowledge to arabs in his days.

[yahmana]

@yougonasorry my friend I speak arabic, and Alaqaa doesn't mean blood clot. and this proves to you it's different from what the greeks thoughts. Alaqaa means a leech in arabic & not menstruation blood like the greeks thoughts. do you know what a leech is? the human embryo looks like a leech in early development & that's what alaqaa means. type leech in google translator & translate to arabic then hit the sound button to hear alaqaa & try menstrual you'll hear a different word.

[yahmana]

@yougonasorry muslims have faith in god & they don't need science to believe in existence of true god, also you should know that scientists are human beings & hence they are prone to errors just like any other human being but god can never be in error. The translator of the quran is also a human being & he is prone to errors but the original word of god without the translation is error free.

[yougonasorry]

@yahmana So let's not drift from the subject we were talking about how manymuslims praised the quran to be a mircale because it was talking about embryology, and thus muslims started stating recently'how could muhammed have discovered that,he didn't have a microscop and he was iliterate, so it must be divine' . I just told you that the embryology part in the quran was plagariased (quite obviously) from greek philosophers and there is nothing divine about it, hence your argument crumbled

[yougonasorry]

@yahmana when i said 'scholars; i referred to the muslim one who started that alaqaa means blood clot , exactly the same as the greeks thought, they actually thought that the menstruation blood played a role in the creation of the embryo thats why they Galen included something similar in his work. I REALLy dont understand how you can deny that all the embryoloy part in the quran was taken from many different sources (galen, aristotle, that hindu scholar dont remember the name, hippocra.

[yougonasorry]

@yahmana wrong... actually there was a place a dont remember the name, where people from different culture met, and if you ead the greek medecin history you would know that EXACTLY a few years before mohamed was born, mededin knowledge on embryology was passed on from mouth to mouth there were huge volumes about many medecinal branches in the library of alexandria however it was very easy just to pass on mouth to mouth, that explains the many error in the quran

[yahmana]

@yougonasorry Islamic scientists (few years after MO died & spread over many parts of the world) fixed many of the Greeks errors, it's not the other way around where Muslims stole knowledge from Greeks. Translation errors could happen but its no fault of quran. there are many scientific theories that get refuted so if the Quran said something & scientist said something different it wouldn't mean the Quran is wrong & it would probably mean science is wrong or translation is wrong.

[yahmana]

@yougonasorry I am just wondering how many greeks scholars that knew embryology who actually lived or even visited the same country where MO lived ! there were only 16 people who could read & write in that country during that time. you said "scholars said", you are probably talking about christians who are trying to teach against islam (obviously they are biased & they don't speak arabic). as I said look it up in dictionary (dictionary can't be wrong).