Carly Smithson - Here You Come Again - American Idol Top 9
Loading...
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
All Comments (40)
-
@Theatreguy34 I envy you for having seen her live. In my humble opinion, Carly has one of the best voices in Idol history. Given the right circumstances, I'm sure she could have followed the same path as Clarkson and Underwood. There's still time. I don't think we've heard the last of her.
-
@GospelAccording2ME It was Cook vs Archuleta. But Carly is AMAZING. I saw her on the Idols Live tour and she was even better live. I wanted the final three to be Cook, Carly and Michael Johns... Alas I was wrong *sigh*
-
@Theatreguy34 I actually liked some of the stuff Cook performed. I still don't get why America picked him, though. He seemed mundane and safe. Again, I'm having a lapse in memory...I can't even recall who David Cook competed against. But, I remember Carly.
-
@GospelAccording2ME David Cook won this season.
-
She can sing her ass off. There's no reason she shouldn't have won this season. As a matter of fact, I don't even recall who won this season...but, I remember Carly.
-
Love this version.
-
@BarBaSoil they're totally different arrangements, Clay's keeps the spirit of the original while Carly makes the song sad
-
After Kelly Clarkson shes probably my favourite vocalist from idol. Its just a shame she wasnt as good a performer as say, kelly clarkson, and didnt get the right song choices. But you have to remember, she walked in from the street to an audition with THAT VOICE.
1 year ago 2
-
She stole Clay Aiken's arrangement and never gave credit. Boo.
-
I'm agreeing with mskapay!
- 2:04Why Chris Brown Beat Rihannaby nigahiga23,044,873 views
Featured Video
- 3:32Carly Smithson, The show must go on Studio Ver...by biancawoehlk19,583 views
- 1:49American Idol 7 - Top 9 - Brooke White - Joleneby wookiielover1,086,068 views
- 1:55Carly Smithson - Without You - American Idol Top 7by bonk6515,919 views
- 1:47Carly Smithson - I drove all nightby irishsweethearttx9,996 views
- 3:13Carly Smithson Without You Studio Version - videoby biancawoehlk12,157 views
- 2:30Kelly Clarkson "without you" results showby InFINITI2818,829 views
- 1:39Kristy Lee Cook - Coat Of Many Colors - America...by bonk6520,213 views
- 2:38Somewhere Over The Rainbow - Katharine McPhee (...by derrick3204,840,187 views
- 2:51Carly Smithson - Here You Come Again LIVE at Th...by CarlySmithsonMusic2,835 views
- 1:59Syesha Mercado - I Will Always Love You Americ...by bonk65124,762 views
- 3:26Clay Aiken - Here You Come Againby Claysidney34,768 views
- 1:35Carrie Underwood - Aloneby pravinmelwani5,231,368 views
- 4:32American Idol 7 - Top 9 - Carly Smithson - Here...by wookiielover190,495 views
- 1:56Carly Smithson - Total Eclipse of the Heartby babsieholic5,235 views
- 3:51Here You Come Again - Clay Aikenby LovesClaysVoice1,009 views
- 5:53Carly Smithson - Come Together - American Idolby Caliiniiqka18304,641 views
- 1:56Carly Smithson - Blackbirdby babsieholic30,113 views
- 2:15Michael Johns Season 7 Top 9 April 1st American...by bl00dys0uls25,819 views
- 3:10Carly Smithson - Alone (Hollywood Week)by CarlySmithsonMusic175,001 views
Simon said on the Top 7 results show that he holds Carly to a higher standard because she is so talented that he expect excellence. I guess that seems fair. She is something special indeed.
cbotten106 3 years ago 6
For me, her best performance so far
crisengineer 3 years ago 6