CARNIFEX - Answers in Mourning [MTV2 Music Video]

**edit** alright, so we all know the breakdown is similar to a song called "Through Struggle" by the band As I Lay Dying. as everyone knows it, please stop commenting about it and crying whether Carnifex or AILD is a better band. Although, I hate metalcore...metal is metal..if it sounds good, then it sounds GOOD!

Carnifex's Answers in Mourning Music Video
This song (not the video) is from their album 'The Diseased & The Poisoned 2008'

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Carnifex
• Answers
• in
• Mourning
• Video
• CZW
• BJW
• IWA
• Suicide
• Silence
• Chelsea
• Grin
• Brutal
• Deathcore
• Band
• Song
• ever
• sick
• br00tal
• breakdown
• death
• metal
• melodic
• folk
• technical
• fast
• power
• black
• symphonic
• growl
• grunts
• pig
• squeals

[emandemon1]

HAHAHA. At 1:10 that's the same breakdown as Through Struggle by As I Lay Dying.

[CyborgPunisher]

@emandemon1- o really? :)

[1stBroly]

lol same breakdown like as i lay dyings through struggle. 1:1. lol^^

[CyborgPunisher]

@1stBroly just one question. if they copied the breakdown, wouldn't they know the criticism the band would face?

[garretts431]

I saw this on MTV. Why the fuck did MTV have to change. fuck lil' wayne.

[Necrephorus]

MTV had so many fucking awesome bands,like Nile and carnifex.... fuck new mtv

[ElijahJohnCirricione]

@emandemon1 As I Lay Dying took the breakdown from them. but really, it doesn't matter

[xxXCrabcoreXxx]

headbangers ball... remember? :/

[IamTheDeathMachine]

the through struggle breakdown sounds a tad different. I can tell

[a7xrulz96]

What's with all the As I Lay Dying gay faggot shit? They suck. Carnifex Rules. Point made

[Xenon797]

kicks as i lay dyings ass

[Powerman6002]

@emandemon1 no its not they are close not the same though

[TheTrueHunter]

This gets me PUMPED!

[SharkChode]

@emandemon1 Lmao, are you kidding? Firstly, no it isn't, you can clearly tell in the second verse of Carnifex' breakdown they continue the down-up stroke to coincide with the drums, AILD doesn't.

SECONDLY, every single breakdown sounds pretty much exactly like this at point. It's hard to be creative with a breakdown, they're meant to just be churning moments in a song.

[StrYke4707]

As I Lay Dying and Carnifex are both great bands! Just different styles and genre.