Saying YA RASOOLALLAH Allowed or Not-- Shaykh Muhammad Al Yaqoubi.flv

No description available.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Saying
• YA
• RASOOLALLAH
• Allowed
• or
• Not
• Shaykh
• Muhammad
• Al
• Yaqoubi
• ntermediary
• Halwa
• Halva
• Mulla
• Exposed
• Yusuf
• Estes
• Islam
• zakir
• naik
• Yahya
• Ninowy
• on
• Noor
• Bashar
• Bashhariyat
• Bashariyat
• Naeemi
• Ja
• Haq
• Bashariyyat
• Nur
• Zakir
• human
• being
• Biddat
• Bidat
• Biddati
• bidati
• Mawlid
• Meelad
• Milad
• Al-Y'aqoubi
• Syria
• Shaam
• Shirk
• Tawassul
• Shia
• Bareilwy
• Brelvi
• Haqforum
• Shura
• Taliban
• Deobandi
• Tablighi
• Tariq
• Jamil
• dr.
• Israr
• Ahmed

[littlefeefi1]

1, Our Beloved Prophet sallAllahu alaihi wa aalihi wa sallam is living but is veiled from our unrighteous eyes.

2, Allah ta'ala knows the intention, even if it is not uttered aloud.

Conclusion- Ya Rasul Allah is perfectly acceptable based on appropriate intention

[sunnidawah]

ma'shallah may allah persarve and bless sayadi shaykh muhammad al yaqoubi

[ayatullah100b]

@benotignorant1 please provide your proof if you are truthful. And the hadeeth you are talking about is zaeeef,

[benotignorant1]

@ayatullah100b This isn't true,you can give the salam to the prophet directly out of salah as recorded by many ahadith.

salam alaik ya rasulallah anywhere and anytime is allowed.

[ayatullah100b]

@benotignorant1 Well there are two places which are only permissible to say Ya Rasool Allah in all aspects of Islam and i am not a scholar to give my Expert opinion on it. These two places are (In Azan-Ashad Anna Muhammad ur Rasool Allah) and in tashahud (Asalam alaika ayunhan nabiyu) and no where else its permissible, thats what many scholars say. I am just a student.

[ayatullah100b]

@benotignorant1 Well i didn't say that, but this is very sensitive issue, we have to avoid things which are ambiguous in religion, because when i hear many people saying ya Rasool Allah, i find them in great misunderstanding, which does not adhere to fundamental teachings of Islam. Its a bidah and every bidah is misguidance and every misguidance is in fire....... full stop.

[benotignorant1]

@ayatullah100b Where do you make this stuff up?

"Ya" in Arabic is an invoking particle,so yes you are calling upon rasulallah,but it isn't ibadah.

Like I call to you "ya ayatullah salam alayk" im not worshiping you.

[ayatullah100b]

@ByChoiceMuslim No its not. But it does not mean you are calling on to Rasool Allah.

[ByChoiceMuslim]

@ayatullah100b So when we say "Peace be upon you O Prophet" in the prayer is that shirk.

[afzal345345]

sirif YA ALLAH

[ayatullah100b]

In Islam whatever you claim, you have to prove it with authentic source, that comes from Allah and His Messenger (SAWS), it only said that the earth does not eat the body of messengers. It doesn't mean we can say YA Rasool Allah. We have to look at facts and follow Islam in true way not by listening to anyone make up his own mind. If something is ambiguous, we must avoid rather than following blindly, because thats the way of Yahood and Nasara and we may fall in the trap of Satan.

[12imams]

@kadafi150 the koran says: those who die in the way of Allah SWT, nay they are alive and your DONT percieve".. so we dont dont doubt the prophet PBUHF died for the cause of Allah SWT. so he is alive in a way we cant comprehend.. ill give you an extreme example.. do you know that Iblis is alive.?? yes he is, but we cant see him.. yet you believe in that right? so the Prophet is protected in another way/method/dimension, and the koran says believers trust in the "unseen".!