Philippe Jaroussky~Rolando Villazón:Sì dolce è 'l tormento
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (23)
-
Jaroussky sings in a headvoice, and Villazon uses his chestvoice. The first is a countertenor, the second a normal tenor. They cannot be compared.
Both good, though, in their own unique way. (But I prefer Jaroussky when it comes to this repertoire)
-
j'aime les deux versions ... très différentes , la version de Jaroussky me parait plus barroquen celle de Villazon plus italienne...
-
Jaroussky, wonderful as always!
-
Jaroussky's voice is very beautiful, but his italian pronunciation is terrifying, and I find that the instrumental accompaniment in Villazon's version is more refined.
-
@JaRoWi1647 the one, who has prejudices are you? who said that we should compare them to degrade the other one? you have to see it like a vase that is enlightened by 2 different rays of light...
-
I listened to all 3 versions, PJ, RV, and MZ. Each has own beauty, but I feel I can listen to JP anytime and anywhere,
-
The main joke is that Jaroussky put most women opera singer to shame. He is mor original then women voices. For that Jaroussky is the sky and haven.
LP
-
I am a great Jaroussky fan, but I tip my hat to Rolando here.
-
Rolando is great!
I ´m really interested, what will come as the next - maybe, you should compare von Otter with Quasthoff or Dessay with Pavarotti- it would be the same result: incomparable .
In this case you can´t compare the ravishing rare voice of PhJ with an ordinary good one of RV. Sorry.
JaRoWi1647 2 years ago 6
La voz de Jaroussky te lleva al corazón la música pura, casi intocada, digamos que etérea, mientras que Villazón canta con su corazón y es él quien nos habla. aquí la pasión está en Villazón y su interpretación...
¿Cuál de las dos? ¡Las dos!
reinadegrillos 1 year ago 4