Gentle Giant - Civilian - 02 - All Through the Night
Uploader Comments (progrocker69)
All Comments (20)
-
Sorry, what I meant to ask was: did you find anything "decent" in this album? I'm going to try another one.
-
Did you find it? This song, honestly enough, is not the genius Gentle Giant most of us revel at. It's not a bad song, it's sung properly (the voice is there) and played in a competent manner. But to say it sounds like Gentle Giant...
-
@mirkodelmedico è solo uno stile diverso da quello che usano solitamente, e perdipiù sono convinto che questo pezzo nasconda una discreta complessità... non dovresti liquidarlo così
-
gentle giant and king crimson definitely made progressive (rock and metal) what it is today without them dream theater, opeth and numerous other may have never existed. And when a band can pull away from itself and experiment most of the time it ends up being epic.......prime example with this song
-
Splendida canzone ottimo gruppo questo e' il vero rock.
-
Some may find this cut at least a bit catchy. Civilian's misstep wasn't its genre, but its lack of distinction -- there have certainly been less virtuosic bands, as The Beatles, whose oeuvre is unforgettable. Civilian, though technically clean, simply doesn't give us GG's creative best, which, as I recall, a band member or two has admitted. To "NFLed": No snobbery, then, is needed to regard Giant's other albums (e.g., TF, O, IAGH, FH and TPATG) as essential to the collection, unlike Civilian.
-
I guess I'm part of the prog snob crowd (although I don't slam yes, king crimson, or even genesis for what they want to do) because this song doesn't do much of anything for me as it's just a straight rocker (for a straight rocker it isn't anything close to the good stuff of Zeppelin etc.). I'm a huge GG fan for dozens of years up through The Missing Piece but not Giant for a Day. I'll try other Civilian stuff, though, in case I'm missing something decent.
This remind me disco music haha
alexbarcena 1 year ago
@alexbarcena This doesn't sound like disco at all. If you want a more progressive band moving heavily into disco territory, check out ELO's "Discovery" or "I Wouldn't Wanna Be Like You" by the Alan Parsons Project.
And excuse me if I'm costing myself any credibility, but there are some disco tunes that are very well done. Almost as many as ones that totally suck.
progrocker69 1 year ago
This song proves that Gentle Giant could play any kind of style they wanted. This is one of their heavier songs and Gary Green does a fantastic job on the guitar. Looks like they Gary, Kerry & former drummer Malcom Mortimore are back under the sugestive name "Three Friends". No Shulman brothers on this new ensemble, but is good to know that at least part of the Giant has awakened from a very long sleep. Long live the Giant !
sauerix 2 years ago 5
Absolutely true on all counts! I'm going to be trying to post some other missing Giant tracks soon, I think. There are so many others that should be here.
I started with tracks from "Civilian" because I think this album gets nowhere near enough respect from the "prog snob" community. They're the same people who are busy slamming Yes, King Crimson and everyone else for daring to try and become a little more accessible while still making great music.
They couldn't be more wrong.
progrocker69 2 years ago 2