白鹤 -詠春拳(七步三战) - Chinese Sanchin
Uploader Comments (XingYiQuanArgentina)
Top Comments
-
wooow!!! excelent performance!!! Strong Master!!!
-
Very elegant.
All Comments (58)
-
what is the song name?
-
I think on here people have ruined the chance of many to find an art and want to explore it. Though the video's help, to a point, the style, moves, and what is out there. What pisses me off is the Armchair warriors that "talk" about other systems, refer to "books". In combat I won't give a F**k what you read. You better have my back cause I know only me and my potential so I know I will have yours. So, all you "Burger King karate" experts needs to train more and read less.
-
Why only practice Sanchin ? What is so special about "Sanchin" ?
-
perhaps it's more accurate to say that the hsing-I has dropped out of the Goju ryu, and it should get put back in?
have you noticed how well the goju movements integrate with the 5 elements movements, especially Pi Chuan?
that's the puzzle of all this stuff, to find the essence that's beyond the strictness of a style.
all styles have good and bad points, benefit from the good, adjust to minimize the bad. everyone progresses on their own path...
-
@stillnessinmovement - Oh I understand all this. But I've been a Goju Ryu practitioner 36 years and I also trained in Hsing I Chuan. There is no Hsing I Chuan at all in Goju Ryu. The fact that he learned it, does not mean he included it in his teaching. I have Mark Bishop's book. The breathing in White Crane Samchien is different from Goju Ryu's breathing. Sure, they are supposed to lead to the same results, but do they? Okinawan Sanchin has been linked to imbalances - but not White Cranes.
-
had to comment
Higaonna reputedly learned sanchin kata, and some hsing-I, while in china. check mark bishop's book.
additionally, the change in the specifics of the movement is not a major consequence. It's the breathing and internal power development methods that connect them.
keep in mind that 110 years ago, what we now call goju, shotokan, isshin ryu, etc, all had the same name.
and that name was... China Hand.
roots are in chinese gung fu...
argentine kung fu wow.
bigkittysmile 4 months ago
@bigkittysmile thanks for your comment.
XingYiQuanArgentina 4 months ago
This guy looks strong, good posture - looks more like a taiji/bagua guy then white crane though (as much as you can tell from basic body shape), so would prefer to see him doing those form then this one. Southern mantis sarm bo jin is a much better version too. ;)
deadlypalms 4 months ago
@deadlypalms en breve voy a postear un clip de mantis sureña., gracias por los comentarios.
XingYiQuanArgentina 4 months ago
很不錯!!
73vocado 5 months ago
@73vocado 非常感谢您的评论
XingYiQuanArgentina 5 months ago