Windsbacher Knabenchor: Weihnachtsoratorium IV
Uploader Comments (Jairdan)
All Comments (29)
-
Really tenoruser? If I google Marcel Ponseele, I see photos of a man that is clearly not the same person in this video...
-
@jamagaw that is Marcel Ponseele. A GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRREAT player and musician. And with a great sense of humour too!
-
They should have credited the fantastic oboist...
-
also, that girl is almost as beautiful as the music. :)
-
the "echoing" (I'm an idiot) eg around 2:20 or so is beautiful...
-
She has a beautiful voice!
-
windsbacher knabenchor ist ein super chor und es hat verdammt viel spaß gemacht in ihm zu singen!
und dadurch dass herr beringer (der dirigent) Gegangen ist hat der chor einen verdammt guten dirigenten verloren!)=
-
Cette interpétation est magnifique et mémorable à tous égards, merci !
Dolmetscher Das ist schön und unvergesslich in jeder Hinsicht, danke!
Please.. what is this work? I have never before heard it - and how beautiful it is!
strachs100 1 year ago
@strachs100 This is Part IV of the Christmas Oratorio by Johann Sebastian Bach (BWV 248 IV)
Aria [female Soprano here /boy treble in Bachs time] with Echo [treble] + Oboe solo, Continuo
Jairdan 1 year ago
"It is always done that way ..." Perhaps I should leave it at that, because there are many aspects of life about which the same thing is said, but that are discovered to be wrong. I believe in the integrity of the boy's voice in obbligato with an oboe da caccia, and therefore, it matters not to me what other pairing may be utilized; that said, it does seem to me that a woman's voice paired in obbligato with a modern oboe seems to be a good fit as well.
maestrovoci 4 years ago
In my opinion it is not about right or wrong. Music is an art and there are different interpretations and ways classical music is performed. Boys voices have a different quality and a beauty of their own and I enjoy that, but I don't think it would be right if it is the only performed that way. I love diversity and those who claim they do it "historical" are often as narrow minded as their opponents. I love both.
Jairdan 4 years ago 2