Tawassul - Is it really shirk?

This is a video that presents the evidence for tawassul from the holy Qur'aan and the hadith. I will accept video responses from those who disagree so we can have a debate.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• tawassul
• tawasul
• mediation
• wahhabi
• wahabi
• salafi
• shirk
• bid'a
• bid3a
• innovation
• grave
• worship
• sufi
• sofi
• islam
• islaam
• muslim
• moslim
• du'a
• du3a
• dua

[hunker87]

ni sufis sejer att ibn taymiyah var den första som var emot tawassul ; Imâm Abû Hanîfah (rahimahullâh) – dog 150 H, 511 år före Imâm Ibn Taymiyyahs födsel, 661 H – sade: ”Det är förbjudet att säga: ”Jag ber Dig vid den och den” eller ”vid Dina profeter och sändebud…” Sharh al-´Aqîdah at-Tahâwiyyah, sid. 334, av Imâm Ibn Abîl-´Izz al-Hanafî, Sharh al-Fiqh al-Akbar, sid. 198, av ´Allâmah ´Alî al-Qârî al-Hanafî.

[mainstreamIslam]

@hunker87 Nej, vi säger inte detta. Det vi säger är att Wahhabiter är de enda som ansett tawassul vara shirk. Abu Hanifa sa aldrig att det är shirk!

[0515524847]

NO asking your mother for prayers is absolutely opposite to asking Prophets for prayers. Because when one asks his her mother for prayers, She is alive & there to pray for her child. No body in his/her right minds will go to her dead mother's grave & ask her to do prayers for him/her.

You can ask me to pray for you & i can ask you the same. The problem is when we ask for prayers from a dead person.

Peace

[mainstreamIslam]

@0515524847 all your objections have been answerd on the video and in the comments. But thanks for trying your best.

[0515524847]

@mainstreamIslam well i am still waiting XD

[mainstreamIslam]

@0515524847 What are you waiting for? I told you where the answer to your question is. Just wtch the video and then relate to my answers, and stop repeating yourself like a parrot.

[SurahTaHaForever]

so if the "salafis" are right then over 1000 years of Muslim scholars were all kaffirs and mushriks.. damn.

[a4fkntrippen]

It's intension if you know in your heart Allah is the decision maker then tawassul is not shirk at all. Who ever says it is be aware of what you say because you are going to be held accountable for all the people who believe you.

[nawazsucks]

@0515524847 Every Prophet and saint is alive as Quran 2:154 says that do not call a marytr dead, although you think he's dead, you perceive it not. And a martyr is a person doing Jih'ad and struggle, and dies during it. And these saints do Jihad to make people come towards Islam (Prophet Muhammad (SAW), All other 123999 prophets, and saints like Mevlana Rumi, Data Hajweri, Ajmer Sharif, Ahmed Shah Masood, Shahbaz Qalander. made struggle and are alive in thier graves.

[MissConceptions1]

I can't post this video on FB because wahhabis have reported it as being 'abusive'... alsong with MANY other videos so FB has blocked them! Wahhabi Cowards fear the truth!

[Synergistik]

It's a strange thing to say seeking help from the dead is shirk, because they can't help you, but from the living is fine, because they can. NO one can help you accept Allah. Dead or alive is irrelevant. Are those who claim it's shirk if the person is dead, guilty themselves of shirk when they say the living can help? Certainly not! Something is not right here.

We one makes tawassul, one seeks the help of Allah through the position and rank a person has with Him, and His love for this person.

[DaKosovali]

@Anonymous01011

who are kuffar? Those who perform Tawassul? if yes, why?

[Anonymous01011]

kuffars!!!

[EngjellAlbani]

@mainstreamIslam

Assalamu alaykum

May Allah reward you for defending tawassul. Something nobody classified as shirk before Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahhab. .

btw, Can you please tell me who is reciting Qasida Burda, and if it is available on youtube?

Wassalam

[Mrpolice333]

The Quran is written in Arabic not English. Words could be out if context? As there is really a 100% accurate English to Arabic translation???