J.R.R. Tolkien sings 'Troll Sat Alone On His Seat Of Stone'
Uploader Comments (chamberofrecords)
Top Comments
-
i love this song! my grandpa loved lotr and he used to sing this to me as a lullaby when i was a little lass!!
-
Yeah, he did, but it's not funny.
Back when this was written, almost every word in the English language didn't mean something bad.
All Comments (101)
-
He's got a fine Irish accent on him there.
-
@vampirehunteramanda I forgive you. What else can I do?
-
@kobidobidog There is nothing wrong with sexual expression, nor did I state it was revolting in any way. I merely stated my annoyance over immature viewers who automatically giggled over the current usage of the word boner and not even bothering to realise Tolkien meant something completely different. I apologise if I wasn't clearer in my explanation.
-
@vampirehunteramanda Pray tell what is wrong with sexual? Please tell me. Would it be we thought about war in the way you are repulsed by sexual innuendo.
-
It sounds like he's really havin' a good time, reading this, almost as if he was dancing around in his library with a half-full glass in his hand.. lol
-
@AndrewzDescent I respectfully disagree, friend. This is when the immature English speakers become the majority of posters. >_< I am an American in my twenties who bothers to read the old classics such as Beowulf and other such works. Never once do I attach sexual meanings to these songs.
Huzzah for J.R.R Tolkien! Namarie!
-
Interesting. Some of the words are different. I do know the Lord of the Rings was edited to be more consistent more than once; most notably he probably changed the names because John and Jim don't work as hobbit names.
well as chamberofrecords put what was in the book, this must be an earlier version of the song, as tolkien did do a fair piece of revising. i learned the tune for this and all the other songs from the great rob inglis who did the audio books, but this is wonderful as well. well, its tolkien singing it, so it would be.
Gawaine687 3 years ago
Indeed, I accidentally copy-pasted the wrong version. As you say, the text to the right is from the book, and the audio an earlier version.
chamberofrecords 3 years ago