The Carousel Museum Hurdygurdy
Uploader Comments (yvettegr)
Top Comments
-
This is not a hurdy gurdy. A hurdy gurdy is an instrument with strings and keys that stop the strings so you can play any tune you want. Barrel organs, band organs, and carousel organs play a fixed tune and do not usually have strings, although I have seen band organs with violins that are bowed with a mechanical arm and played with mechanical fingers. Interesting video. Thanks for posting.
-
Thats a band organ
All Comments (26)
-
Organology, the study of the structure, use, and classification of musical instruments, is the science used by museums to classify instruments. They can't just apply any name they want to a musical instrument. Might as well call a guitar a banjo! I've studied and played the Gurdy for years and I know of no countries that refer to band organs as hurdy gurdies. Barrel organs are sometimes called hurdy gurdies, although this is also incorrect. The museum is in error and needs to correct it.
-
Organology, the study of the structure, use, and classification of musical instruments, is the science used by museums to classify instruments. They can't just apply any name you want to a musical instrument. Might as well call a guitar a banjo! I've studied and played the Gurdy for years and I know of no countries that refer to band organs as hurdy gurdies. Barrel organs are sometimes called hurdy gurdies, although this is also incorrect. The museum is in error and needs to correct it.
-
@1955thekeeper Yeah, language is not stagnant, and some terms mean different things in different parts of the country. The Carousel Museum referred to it as a Hurdy Gurdy. What museums did you go too? I'm always looking for new museums to visit.
-
@yvettegr I agree with you. I am 56 years old and in my youth I was privileged to be able to go to several museums which dealt with turn of the century modes of entertainment and every time one of these contraptions were present the term "Hurdy Gurdy" was applied. One I remember had a crank in the end of it like the old starting crank on a Model T. When you turned it it charged up a spring until the tension became too great then the device would begin to play until it wound down. TFP
-
The violin one would actually be a orchestrion.
-
@wurly164 WurliTzer 105
-
Thats a wurliTzer 105 band organ
IT'S ALIVE!
Synith 1 year ago
@Synith Ha Ha! Someone knows their horror films.
yvettegr 1 year ago