(jewish / muslim part 2) Why I Choose To Be Jewish Over 'Islam'

He is consistent in His ways.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• judaism
• jew
• christians
• become
• muslim
• join
• islam

[silversmoke100]

Salaam, my thought is that God could have preserved the book but then, what would the point of the test be? He could have made saiten bow to Adam because he has power in infinite amount so why didn't he? Also he could have denied saiten long life and vanished him into nothing, but then what would be the point of a hell? And he could have made us without will like the angels but then what would the point of existence be?

[omedyashar]

@silversmoke100

Why do you think your question "Salaam, my thought is that God could have preserved the book but then, what would the point of the test be?" is applicable to Torah but not to the Qur'an as well?

[silversmoke100]

Salaam, I have another question and this question is to the Jews only. Do you believe Abraham and Mosses (PBUT) were messengers or sons of god?

[omedyashar]

@silversmoke100

We do say that those who love G-d are His "sons," but this is only in a metaphorical sense. It is forbidden to understand it literally. In Hebrew, anyone who agrees with a particular group or idea can be called a 'son' of that thing.

Abraham and Moses were messengers and prophets of G-d. G-d has no actual sons or daughters. According to Jews, it is blasphemy to teach that G-d has sons, daughters, a mother, father, brother, sister, or that anything is comparable to Him.

[silversmoke100]

Salaam. Torah is the word of god not of Moses he just bought the message to them the Jews. I have 2 questions? my Question is if the Torah was complete then why did Jesus come to them the Jews? And why did the rest of the messengers come to the Jews?

[omedyashar]

@silversmoke100

The Torah teaches that future prophets will come who will warn us of disasters and tell us to repent lest those disasters become reality. Read through the "Old Testament" prophets and you will see a BIG difference between the books of the prophets and the Torah. The Torah is packed with laws, whereas prophets after Moses only encouraged the people to RETURN to upholding the Torah's laws. They may also tell us what the outcome of an event may or may not be.

[Snake2k33]

@omedyashar Salamoalaikum.. I was reading the Quran.. and watched your videos.. I dont think old faiths should be rejected according to the Quran.. All that God says in the Quran is (for the idolaters) Stop idolatry, (for the cruel/tyrants) make peace, (For the Jews) accept Mohammad (pbuh) as the Prophet of God and stay true to what you were taught, (For the christians) stop calling Jesus God's son go back to your true teachings [pure monotheism like jews and muslims]..

[ghostmanno12]

Just because God is above change does not mean that Humans have different needs or that God can Will differently to people at different times. You also put down laws on what God can and cannot do.

Religion is acting according to revelation and knowing God from what God tells us. It is not believing in what is convenient for us and assuming God is what we assume God to be.

[rezanoei]

the problem is that most jews don't go to torah for guidance but istead use talmud( a book written by a man ) as their authoritative book and their laws are based on talmud's directives and not torah. AND U ARE WRONG , Quran is preserved in original language .. the translations are never considered as Quran but more like as making life easier for those who don't understand the arabic language.. but to know what's in it, we only refer to the arabic language in order to clarify things...

[rezanoei]

u are wrong cuz people at the time of other prophets didn't have the capacity to understand and obey a complete guidance from God... religion was brought to man little by little until its completion by the last prophet ( Mohammad ) pbuh. humans were like kids starting school.. u never go on to teach a kid materials from university but u start with very basic knowledge until the kid is mature enough to understand the rest..

[CreatureParallax]

@omedyashar @silversmoke100 hopefully it gets to both of you, in a sense why does the Almighty need to test us if we are his creation then we are but him are we not (we are made in the image of Adonai/Allah as it states in the Torah or what the Islamics call it (pardon the lack of term), not just in it but the beginings of it) if then arn't we all the same. What we practice is not wrong no matter how we practice it, as long as its "Gods" will.

[UnderstandingAll]

Musa (Peace Be Upon Him) ----Isa (PBUH)---- Muhammad(Peace Be Upon Him) You need 2 acknowledge all the Messengers along with their respected message. Torah - Gospel - Qur'aan Watching the big picture vs picking at the puzzle pieces we can better understand the Truth.

[mydreams82]

The Christian bible is a colection of writings from various authours whit parables,advice and dreams all toghether in 1 book.Same whit the jewish Torah.

But the Qur'an is only 1 book writing by 1 man in his own lifetime.It is mostly direct commands.

The Qur'an is no picking and choosing.It says very explicitly and in no uncertain terms that a muslin must not alter or ignore any part of its very clear and direct message or they will burn in a fiery torment forever.

[mydreams82]

22.Islam has not been hijacked.That islam has been hijacked is what non-muslims naturally assume because they assume all religions are the same.The reason non muslims are so easily confused is that most of us dont realize the difference between the Qur'an and every other religions book we are familiar whit.

The Christian bible is a colection of writings from various authours whit parables,advice and dreams all toghether in 1 book.Same whit the jewish Torah.

[mydreams82]

@omedyashar ...........1.The islamic sciptures teach that Jesus never actually died on the cross.He is alleged to have departed from the cross before fully expiring.This is simply historically inaccurate,however,as essentially no New Testament historian (event the most radically anti-Cristian) believes Jesus survived crucifixion.

2

[ghostmanno12]

muslims dont think that the world was in darkness for all that was before Muhammad peace be upon him. The Quran even says that the jews and christians are not all the same- some pray in the night and recite the scripture. notice the word scripture there. further: the Quran says that Jews and Christians who do righteous deeds and believe in God and the last day will have no fear on them.

[ghostmanno12]

Your video talks about you rejecting islam - but it is really a video about why you chose judaism over islam

Without answering to critics and what Muslims say about the bible or torah, can you create a video about what you researched about islam itself and said - well this is what you liked about it, and this is what you disliked?