Part 2 Destinys children India and Pak united in divide

Part 2 of of A Great Debate on CNN INDIA on Thursday, August 16, 2007 in Delhi in front of Humayun's Tomb. Guests include, Actors Amir Khan, Naseeruddin Shah, Pakistan People's Party Member of Pakistan National Assembly, Shahbano "Sherry" Rehman and Imran Khan from Islamabad.

Category:

News & Politics

Tags:

• India

[jojoipaki]

we will never be one thats the final. Quid-i-Azam was right. We are Pakistani and we will be Pakistani.

Good relation between both country can be ok

[xgotfiveonitx]

i think if hindus in india want to be united in one single nation with pakistan, then they should be come muslim. if they cant do that, then they should accept patition once and for all.

[haimiao]

Division Was Right Decision.

But We can be good friends if our leaders want.Also we should solve our problems like KASHMIR.If India leave Kashmir then I think we can be best friends.

[xgotfiveonitx]

well i think that both india and pak should give up each side they control of kashmir and let it be independent of both nations.

[medqueen]

My Nani sacrificed all her life to make pakistan and i never heard her saying that she regreted it NEVER.She loved Quid and we must remember thier QURBANI and make sure our future generation know that thier forefathers did soooooo much for them..Pakistan zindabad..

Yeh but friendship is ecceptable to us!

[shoutforit]

the terrorism in pakistan is the biggest proof that lots of countries r very interested in pakistan being instable. it is stated by interior ministry of pakistan that terrorism in pak is suppoted by foreign elements. u should not worry about our relations with china.its our bussiness. just mind your own bussiness and leave us alone.

[Starnebula100]

This host is such an idiot.

[rallen888]

@haimiao India sent the army only after kash was attacked in 1947 n major contingents after Pak attacked in 1965. Go on youtube and hear your pak journalists like

Najam sethi or Asghar khan or hassan nisar. i am in full favor of peace and removal of army from kash n banning terrorist org in Pok. Live n Let live :)

[rallen888]

In my exp.

Frankly, many Pakis are just bigoted muslims who dont understand their religion but understand only the Islam they learnt from their mullahs.

For Indians, most of them have lil idea about their religion but have relatively more common sense although equally bigoted, again thnx to politics in india.

[rallen888]

Well, i am an Indian. I have lived abroad and known some pakis and their mentality,

I wud never dream or want to unify with pakis as a country. Look at their nation man, it is a result of intolerance and poisoning of their ppl by their leaders.

Not even on the cost if all were to convert to hindus or sikh or become atheist.

I think it is only some old aged indians who still have romance with their British India.

[sankalp4499]

@kabooterjajaja pakistan se zinda bhag

[kabooterjajaja]

PAKISTAN ZINDABAD!!!

[jojoipaki]

Those people who think our culture is same like Indians i will say very big"No". Few stupid people who were reprisenting Islam and still the are thinking they are Muslim i think they should contact with Indian Ulmas who can oppen their eyes.Tehy are too long not Muslim they are just satisfying their selfs like Salman Khan family who let her sister marry with Hindu, like sharukh Khan who married with hindu and teaching a third religion to his children not Muslim either not Hindu.

[jojoipaki]

People like Feroz Khan who also let her daughter marry with Hindu and so many Muslim Actually they are out of Islam. They are just keeping satisfy their self that they are Muslim. If you have any doubt on my comment confrem it from any molana.

These people are runing behind money and wanna be more rich and famious. They will get it what they want in this world but they are the guest of Jahanum.

[nonameisavailable]

no it is not enough. If a hindu person wants to marry a muslim person, this should be fine also. As King Akhbar of the early Muslim period wed a wonderful lady with a hindu faith. THere is no reason for the two countries to become one nation, Economics teaches us that this will be a financial burden on the initiative. But there is no reason why India and Pakistan can't live together just like America and Canada. Travelling freely, making friends, and buying property on either side.