Alert icon
We're changing our privacy policy. This stuff matters.  Learn more  Dismiss

Can World Trust Nato after it deliberately attacked civilians in Serbia and commited war crimes

Loading...

Sign in or sign up now!
Alert icon
Upgrade to the latest Flash Player for improved playback performance. Upgrade now or more info.
2,402
Loading...
Alert icon
Sign in or sign up now!
Alert icon

Uploaded by on Mar 23, 2009

Nato 'deliberately attacked civilians in Serbia' .
By Robert Fisk
Amnesty International on June 7 2000 publishes a blistering attack on the Alliance, accusing it of committing serious violations of the rules of war, unlawful killings and - in the case of the bombing of Serbia's television headquarters - a war crime.
The 65-page Amnesty report details a number of mass killings of civilians in Nato raids and states that "civilian deaths could have been significantly reduced if Nato forces had fully adhered to the rules of war".
The report highlights inconsistencies and obfuscation by Nato's official spokesmen. Although Nato told Amnesty that pilots operated under "strict Rules of Engagement", it refused to disclose details of the "rules" or the principles underlying them. The report says: "They did not answer specific questions Amnesty International raised about specific incidents ..."
Amnesty records that Nato aircraft flew 10,484 strike missions over Serbia and that Serbian statistics of civilian deaths in Nato raids range from 1000 -1200 up to 1,500. It specifically condemns Nato for an attack on a bridge at Varvarin on 30 May last year, which killed at least 11 civilians. "Nato forces failed to suspend their attack after it was evident that they had struck civilians," Amnesty says.
The report says Nato repeatedly gave priority to pilots' safety at the cost of civilian lives. In several investigations of civilian deaths, Amnesty quotes from reports in The Independent, including an investigation into the bombing of a hospital at Surdulica on 31 May.
Amnesty says: "If Nato intentionally bombed the hospital complex because it believed it was housing soldiers, it may well have violated the laws of war. According to Article 50(3) of Protocol 1, [of the Geneva Conventions] 'the presence within the civilian population of individuals who do not come within the definition of civilians does not deprive the population of its civilian character'.
"The hospital complex was clearly a civilian object with a large civilian population, the presence of soldiers would not have deprived the civilians or the hospital compound of their protected status." Some of Amnesty's harshest criticism is directed at the 23 April bombing of Serb television headquarters. "General Wesley Clark has stated, 'We knew when we struck that there would be alternate means of getting the Serb Television. There's no single switch to turn off everything but we thought it was a good move to strike it, and the political leadership agreed with us.'

"In other words, Nato deliberately attacked a civilian object, killing 16 civilians, for the purpose of disrupting Serb television broadcasts in the middle of the night for approximately three hours. It is hard to see how this can be consistent with the rule of proportionality."

The US Defense Department, Amnesty recalls, justified the television station bombing because it was "a facility used for propaganda purposes" and Amnesty itself says that Tony Blair "appeared to be hinting [in a subsequent BBC documentary] that one of the reasons that the station was targeted was because its video footage of the human toll of Nato mistakes ... was being re-broadcast by Western media outlets and was thereby undermining support for the war within the alliance".

Of the Nato destruction of the train at Gurdulica bridge on 12 April, Amnesty says: "Nato's explanation of the bombing - particularly General Clark's account of the pilot's rationale for continuing the attack after he had hit the train - suggests that the [American] pilot had understood that the mission was to destroy the bridge regardless of the cost in terms of civilian casualties ..."

Nato had not, Amnesty adds, "taken sufficient precautionary measures to ensure there was no civilian traffic in the vicinity of the bridge before launching the first attack". Amnesty quotes the Nato spokesman James Shea as admitting that the video of the train shown to the press at the time was speeded up (to three times its original speed) because Nato analysts routinely reviewed tapes at speed.

Mr Shea, Amnesty says, "said that the [Nato] press office was at fault for clearing the tape for public screening without slowing it down to the original speed".

Link to this comment:

Share to:

Top Comments

  • Title answer: No, it can't. I'm discusted that Croatia and Albania are in NATO.

  • that war should have never have happened , clinton was way out of order and all we have done now is attack serbs and foced them out of their country

    NATO needed an excuse to exist and clinton needed to divert attentoip away from his sex scandal

    clinton and wesley clark should be done for war crimes too

see all

All Comments (27)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Nazi Nato,,murdering pigs,,death to nato

  • @jimyb1 "That war should have never happened"

    Ya i agree, the Kosovo War would not happen because the Serbian government started ethic cleansing against ethic Albanians. The Kosovo War is all Serbs' fault. Just like they done in Croatia, Slovenia, and Bosnia before.

  • @656ecko KOSOVO AND ITS PEOPLE WILL PAY FOR THEIR CRIMES JUDGMENT WILL COME ONE DAY BE SURE JUDGMENT WILL COME

  • CROATIA AND ALBANIA MUST PAY FOR THEIR CRIMES OF EXTERMINATION OF INNOCENT MEN, WOMEN AND CHILDREN

  • @656ecko

    Learn to speak English,first.

  • you can suck oll nato trups dick  coze you shulden start war in kosovo but know you oll fuckt bye bye serbio hahahahhaha

  • @Imperial110 TRUE,some already was punished 

  • @Mesina2 Sad znaš kako je kad ti je netko odvratan..........

Loading...

Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more