Carly Smithson American Idol Glendale 2008 Evanescence

Carly Smithson performing Evanescence,'Bring Me To Life'

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Carly_Smithson
• Evanescence
• Bring_me_to_life
• american_idol

[ToxicPoisonTH]

She has a beautiful voice,but she is bad comared to Amy. Amy has one of the most special and unique voice that music industry ever had.Her band "the fallen" should stop copying evanescence cuz they will never be like 'em. Amy invented her own style and they should stop pretending that are being themselves.When I firstly heard this band,was on TV.I saw "Burry me alive"or smth like this n I was with my friend.Before I opened my mouth she said:"This band is copying Evanescence don't you think so?"

[JustinecMouse]

She says she never listened to Evanescence.

Dude! If you have never listened to Evanescence how on earth would you even hear about this song!!!!

Anyway, this is nothing compared to Amy Lee.

Amy Lee ftw.

[agnesbelladonnachili]

@ToxicPoisonTH they does not copy evanscene, i meen evanscene will always be the better, but we are the fallen do not copy them

[SkilynHxC]

@aggiesmoon

Amy is freaking gorgous, for one. For two, who the hell cares about weight? And finally, Amy didn't take the entire four years to write the album. She said she wanted a break from being a celebretely for awhile, and she moved to an apartment in New York. Forgive her for wanting to have a normal life for awhile. -.-

[breakingray]

@ToxicPoisonTH You do realize that We Are the Fallen is the original Evanescence band, minus Amy Lee?

[fuzzyboots38]

Amy is obviously better at singing this song than Carly. Why? Because its Amys/Evanescences song in the first place, it fits her vocals better and Amy throws tons of emotion into her music. Carly simply flips her head around and acts like the popstar she is. Amy understands why this song was written and feels with her music. Carly only sings it because she has Ben Moody, who co-wrote the whole *Fallen album. *(if I'm correct.)

They're both amazing singers, but this round goes to Amy.

[aggiesmoon]

She's skinnier and prettier than Amy Lee. I mean obviously Amy is more talented, Amy can play piano and compose (although slowly, come on one album in 4 years?). Still, Ben obviously chose Carly because she sounded a tiny bit like Amy.

[XxblackrosebushxX]

CARLY SMITHSON WILL NEVER BE AS GREAT AS AMY LEE!!!!

[KiattyKatz]

I can't understand why so many of you are pissed off and letting this take over you. Amy Lee is amazing and has her own voice. So is Carly. So she did a cover of the song, does that mean that every single person who covers Amy Lee in the entire world are pathetic too? Listen to yourselves. We Are The Fallen is amazing and NOT like Evanescence. Why put two amazing singers against each other instead of embracing both of them as the amazing singers they are.

[Emotionsthatrun]

Amy lee is the best, you're ok Carly but Amy is the queen !! 3

[natalieholroyd]

she should sing "show me heaven" has more of the tone for that song than aevanescence song constructive critisism i have a very sensitive ear it would have definately gone better with her voice test me on my theory i bet im right

[funfangtasia90]

Well ... carly makes covers only for bring me to life, going under.. She killed the songs with her "good" voice..BUT if her voice is good enough, why she doesn't sing my immortal??