Why Reincarnation in Hinduism is illogical ?

Loading...

Sign in or sign up now!
Alert icon
Upgrade to the latest Flash Player for improved playback performance. Upgrade now or more info.
2,702
Loading...
Alert icon
Sign in or sign up now!
Alert icon

Uploaded by on Dec 3, 2008

Why Reincarnation in Hinduism is illogical ?

Category:

Education

Tags:

License:

Standard YouTube License

  • likes, 33 dislikes

Link to this comment:

Share to:

Uploader Comments (musaafiir)

  • Who does that Muslim think of himself ?

    I am very sorry for his little knowledge of Hinduism, and off course little knowledge is dangerous thing.

    First, learn the truths of Hinduism, then oppose it or find which is or what is illogical.

    Hinduism never can be illogical, because it is the universal religion, so that all other religions are subset of Hinduism, that's what the ultimate truth is.

    Be sincere and don't make fight of religions.

    Respect all religions.

  • Brother, with due respect: first of all HINDU is never a religion. It's geographical definition. The correct term should be VEDANTIST. Please go back to your original scriptures and see how it differ from Hindu rituals/beliefs that traditionally hisdus practice.

    There is no fighting over religions, it's just examining the concept logically. B'coz TRUTH can definitely face & withstand logical test. Truth shouldn't be shy of logic.

  • Veda doesn't mention about reincarnation. Reincarnation is first mentioned in Upanishad.

    He is wrong to say human being become animal in next life. Reincarnation concept in Hinduism state human takes rebirth as another human in next life according to his/her Karma.

    Why you just count the animal/human only on earth, universe is infinite, next life could be somewhere in another planet in the universe.

  • Brother, He is just quoting what HINDUS widely believe. If u insist he is wrong, then in fact u r asserting HINDU belief is wrong. Hindus DO BELIEVE all living creatures are brothers. Not only animal, Hindus BELIEVE WORST SINNER WILL EVEN BE TREE IN NEXT LIFE. We are just pointing it out as illogical. Actual HINDU belief is not based on your new concept of next life in other planets which you can only imagine with advance knowledge of today.

    Peace & Blessing to you & all...

Top Comments

  • This video is not true, don't believe in this boy, because he doesn't have knowledge of Hinduism.

see all

All Comments (14)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Is this guy a Southern Baptist...or perhaps any christian? He sounds like it.....he reasons like one.

  • what a logic?? to test the parents.. punish the sinless child!!

    god makes people rich - so god gives them easy test?? wrong logic - as it is seen most of the time rich people do not believe in god.

    reincarnation makes more sense - at least u r getting what u did - no one else is responsible.

  • A case has been booked by Arya Samaj on this Honorable Zakir Naik for having misinterpreted the Vedic scriptures and used them in public..

  • Dear Musafir, Similarly I request you to read the concepts of Krma and Ahimsa from the vedas and upanishads also, and not from missionaries like Zakir Naik, Ninan or Deivanayagam.

  • Friends, Great saints and Gurus have acknowledged the concept of karma and reincarnation. Even Shirdi Sai Baba claimed to be the rebirth of the Sufi saint Kabir Das. Please tell Mr.Zakir Naik to study the history of SUFI saints in India.

    The only thing I can say is Muslims have also started brainwashing people, just like how the Christians have done for centuries together.

    My only question is:- WHAT DO YOU PEOPLE GAIN BY CONVERTING SOMEONE TO YOUR FAITH???

  • what a theory. it says that no of people increasing while no of human being icreasing. but no of animals and trees are decreasing drastically. there decreasing rate is higher than humans incerasing rate. as few human kill many trees and animal by destroying jungles. by this logic you can also say that reincarnation may be possible. based on a book of quran you can't deny any thing or justify any thing. serch reincarnation you will find many scientific documentaries.then read papers

  • You are right, hinduism is not like a religion, it is above any religion or religions. No one can truly describe what it is because, the humans do not have power to understand the concept of Hinduism. No body founded it, or no one knows when it began or will end.

    It is eternal truth, the Dharma, or the Sanatan Dharma. The Sacred Vedas form of the fundamental of this concept, which originally belonged to the Eternal God.

    Hinduism accepts all other religions, and the truths.

Loading...

Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more