Mark Pagel: How language transformed humanity
Top Comments
All Comments (433)
-
Chimpanzees learn by trial and error. Chimps are just smart enough to figure out how to pick up a rock and crack a nut or to use a stick to get an apple on the other side of a fence. But adult chimps don't teach the young chimps. The young ones learn by watching the adults.
A young chimp will take as long as 4 years to learn how to crack a nut with a rock. With language, an adult human can teach a child how to crack a nut in mere seconds.
-
@appolity Not just some in my opinion. He really has some quirky ideas about culture, anthropology, and language
-
There are some points that I disagree with.
-
he tells really lame jokes.
-
Thumbs up for Mr. Swanlund!
-
they teach them stuff by SHOWING them how to hunt. And they only do that out of instinct and necessity. They dont evolve more efficient ways to hunt over time by discussing different methods or trying different tools.
-
Yeah he is absolutely wrong that animals don't have social learning. The big difference is that they don't have language. Which gives us highly symbolic thinking where we can add things together hierarchically creating more complex things.
My question to him is: How did the chimps come up with the tools that they DO use?
triforcelink 6 months ago 13
The most pure example of a theory that uses the status quo to create an account of history.
Hallibutbouy 4 months ago 4