(9/10) Battlefield II The Battle of the Crimea Ep8 World War II
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (24)
-
"Liberation" of the Crimea? o.Ô ...more a change of power...
-
The Allies, possibly British, faked documents and leaked them to the Russians about a plot Stalin's generals were hatching to destroy him. Uncle Joe, as he was known among American government officials, swallowed it hook, line and sinker.
-
@konman001 Not arguing about that. Just pointing out when you have a wealth of documentation -- literally, not just film, mind you -- from one side, and next to nothing from the other (Stalin kept those sorts of statistics and such a closely guarded state secret), you're sort of stuck having to tell the tale from a particular vantage point.
-
@tjhoenecke - When I lived in Poland in the 80s, I saw plenty of WWII footage shot by the Russian side.
I agree that early in WW2 Russians lacked leadership (thanks to dumbass Stalin and his pre-war purges) but later on great talent like Zhukov or Chuikov got a chance at the helm and turned things around. Russians also had the T-34 - overall best tank in WW2.
I agree that Germans had great leadership & training but they also had their share of idiot commanders - Hitler being the biggest one.
-
@konman001 See my earlier comments on a previous installment on this battle. Also, documentaries on the war in Russia tend to come from the German perspective because of the sheer audacity of it. The Germans were vastly outnumbered in terms of men and tanks, but with better training, leadership, and tactics, they almost managed to topple the USSR. It took the Russians three years to cover the same territory the Germans covered in six months. Kind of hard to overlook that.
-
@konman001 See my earlier comments on a previous installment on this battle. Also, documentaries on the war in Russia tend to come from the German perspective because of the sheer audacity of it. The Germans were vastly outnumbered in terms of men and tanks, but with better training, leadership, and tactics, they almost managed to topple the USSR. Kind of hard to ignore that in favor of covering mostly human wave tactics with little regard for losses.
-
Sevastapol looks like a nice place. Plenty of sunshine, especially indoors.
-
meinstein was not in hitlers favor .. if a general faile d he was not good..
-
@vikruss Maybe if you'd paid attention to the documentary you'd realize how full of shit you are.
-
@toffanful Not sure if serious.
Indeed, the earlier looses by the Russias were mainly Stalins fault, having purged his officer core and not tried to do anything to improve his situation by 1941. And ofc, brilliant minds like Patton, Manstein, Yamamoto and Tjujkov can only do so much. Stalin did listen to his senior commanders and took their advice, Hitler did not, so indeed you make a valid point.
TheTrickyFox1976 2 years ago 6
Quite interesting to have the rolls completely reversed now the German's defending.
grannman 2 years ago 5