Refutation of Mohammed2k8 part 4 (allegation 3)

Allegation: The Prophet Nu7 and Lut married disbelieving women so the Prophet Muhammad (S) could have done the same.

Evidences:

http://al-Islam.org/leadership

Please click on the subject on the left hand side that says "The Imam's Communication with the World of the Unseen " and please scroll down to the section where it says:

"Imam al-Baqir, peace be upon him, said: "Once the Commander of the Faithful, 'Ali, peace be upon him, was asked about the extent of the Prophet's knowledge. He replied: 'He had the knowledge of all the preceding prophets; he knew all of the past and all of the future. I swear by God Who holds my soul in His hand that I know all that the Prophet knew, and that I know all of the past and all of the future, up until the Day of Resurrection."' [286]"

Reference for the comment in Usool Al Kafi: pg 185 and it states:

""By listening to the voice of a person, the Imams can tell if the person was destined to go to hell or to heaven; they would thus answer his questions accordingly." (Usool Al-Kafi, p. 185)"

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• Aim786
• muhammad
• koran
• quran
• Islam
• mahdi
• shia'a
• shia
• shi'a
• prophet
• ahmed
• sheikh
• imam

[someonestartwith786]

Hey. I am a shia and I recommend you to read the book "Then I was guided" by Muhammad Al-Tijani, who was a Sunni scholar and converted to Shia. You can find the book online.

[aim786]

@someonestartwith786 I have read that book and I don't find anything significant in there. I would suggest you read a book by Shia'a scholar called " A Critical Revision Of the Shi'a" by Imam Musa Musawi. He is a shia'a who critically analyzes the shia'a ideas and calls for reforms.

[AbuMuslimKhorasani]

The shia compare the mother of believers (ra) with the wives of Lut (as) and Nuh (as) and the proof they give is Surah Tahreem. But these shias forget that Allah (swt) also gaves the example of Maryam (as) and Asiya (as) in the same Surah Tahreem.

[aim786]

@AbuMuslimKhorasani masha Allah EXCELLENT point as well akhee.

[someonestartwith786]

@aim786 Since you've read the book then how do you explain Ali's Wilaya? He was more intitled to be the leader. e.g. the prophet saying he is the gate of knowledge, The ayat of Tathir revealed to the family of the prophet and Ali was included in it. Aisha (r.a) wasn't as seen in the Muslim Sahih Hadeath. Prophet said Ali is like Aron to moses. Prophet took Ali to Mubahila when the quran said take yourself your children and wives. Why did prophet took ali? because ali was his nafs. And much more!

[aim786]

@Notgoingnowhere lol he will become mu7addith over night :)