3. Lily Pons too slow, not enough ring, too swoopy, go back too school.
4... OUCH.
5. sooooo sutherlandish in color, yet she sounds depressed which sutherland never did, scales are smudged. and she pushes at 9'53-9'58, ugly. did she ever hear the vowel "a"? most of this is "o" or "uh". if the "a" is so hard, why does she have no problem with it on the highest notes?
True, 2 isn't Mado! Who is it? Rembolo? Mado had no trill!
gayoperadude63 1 week ago
1. Swenson too velvety for this repertoire.
2. nice but bizarre.
3. Lily Pons too slow, not enough ring, too swoopy, go back too school.
4... OUCH.
5. sooooo sutherlandish in color, yet she sounds depressed which sutherland never did, scales are smudged. and she pushes at 9'53-9'58, ugly. did she ever hear the vowel "a"? most of this is "o" or "uh". if the "a" is so hard, why does she have no problem with it on the highest notes?
wattever333 2 weeks ago
Goar Gasparian has a fantastic version,with very high note!
calaf0911 1 month ago
Claibert's version is fascinating! Nicely rendered, and at times a little strange...i like it...it is a mad scene, after all.
tamerlano 10 months ago
This is not Mado Robin at all!!!
mariokalogeropoulos 2 years ago
#2 is Claire Clairbert, the lovely Belgian coloratura. Love your postings - thank you so much! More Maria Remola please!
milfordbic 3 years ago
I'm confused again...
ritchiereech 3 years ago
June is the best, definitely!
ziapengyfence 3 years ago
Number 1 is June! No question!!!
PogoPera 3 years ago
The number 2 it's not Mado Robin, I am sure!!!
Ce n'est absolument pas la voix de Mado Robin, c'est une erreur!
ioSonoCallas 3 years ago