Once Upon a Time in the West with music from Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End
Uploader Comments (GlenBird)
All Comments (54)
-
Every time i watced , PoTC , i had the strong thought that Mr Zimmer was paying a tribute to Master Ennio's legacy .
-
The score isn't bad at all, but IMO it's just a little too close to being a direct rip-off of the original, rather than a homage to Morricone.
-
welll done Hans , another great job
-
@justis90 i was talking figuratively and i dont believe in GOD since I was born :)
-
Nice music but people are not gods and thats true
-
It is truly interesting to see how composers pay homage to others work by the incorporation utilized in their pieces. This is a great example and it DOES fit both movies. Well done.
-
I find that the original music is less predictable than Hans Zimmers and reflects a death scenery better. Hans Zimmer did a great job with composing the POTC Music and i liked the way he used the E Guitar as a new element to the film music, but in context with a comedy movie the Morricone-Melody looses its power and seriousness, which I find vital for its timeless beauty.
-
i have seen the movie about 200 times.
I love both.
and have to say thank YOU.... because without you, I would not have ever experienced this version.
forget the naysayers... youtube is full of the idiots.
-
I remember thinking how much the music from that sequence reminded me of OUATITW when I was watching it. Made me laugh cuz it was so perfect a match. Glad to know that some current artists know good stuff when they see and hear it.
-
Funny I remember watching that scene and thinking how much the music reminded me of OUATITW. There are a few writers and artists in Hollywood that still know good stuff we they see or hear it.
Hans Zimmer GOD
Ennio Morricone GOD
They are both AWESOME!!
tomsp1138 10 months ago 5
@tomsp1138 Agreed!
GlenBird 10 months ago 3
I'm a huge Morricone fan, but some of the more negative posters here really do need to get a life, or take their pill or something. I found this video to be an interesting illustration of how Zimmers Morricone homage would works in the scene that the original came from. I don't think the poster ever suggested that Zimmers version was better.
MrSwanley 10 months ago 6
@MrSwanley You're absolutely right. I never tried to say Zimmer's version was better, only that he did a fantastic job creating an homage to the original.
GlenBird 10 months ago 2
Fucking horrible. Disgraceful even.
RogueRotting360 1 year ago
@RogueRotting360 I've definitely enjoyed the feedback, both good and bad, that this little video mash-up has gotten. It was a lot of fun to put together and I'd like to thank everyone who has taken the time to respond. I plan to put more videos like this one together soon so keep an eye out for them.
Thanks, Glen
GlenBird 1 year ago 3