Resurrection; Hoax or History (McGill University Debate, 2009)

William Lane Craig debates Shabir Ally on the topic: Did Jesus Rise from the Dead? at McGill University, Quebec, Canada, February 2009.

William Lane Craig's review of the debate could be found at;
http://theresurrectiondebate.wordpres...

Shabir Ally's review of the debate could be found at;
http://shabirally.wordpress.com/2009/...

• Category

  People & Blogs

[Rayes T]

The Codex Sinaiticus and Vaticanus do not record the resurrection:

Matthew 16:2 f. is omitted, Mark ends at 16:8, Luke 22:43 f., John 5:4 and the Pericope de adultera are omitted. The doxology of Romans comes after 16:23. Hebrews follow immediately after II Thessalonians. [2]

[Aida Rashid]

I love Shabir Ally's debates. What a intelligent man, and so patient and tolerant as a debater. Never sarcastic or disrespectful towards others, and so knowledgable about both Islam and Christianity.

[najma omar]

than name them tell me the verse and chapter u found it in.

[pencilpen786]

True that, I must admit



[aronmu]

Amazing how people discuss things they have no way of knowing but have interest to pretend by selecting theories they like! How much energies go into this kind of clownery instead of in first finding out what is really known! It is not only true of religion which has limited relevance, but of all non mathematical sciences! To know things at a level of undisputable direct perception, one should first study Descartes' "Rules for Direction of the Intellect" or the like (and do better than he did).

[Joshuaandcalebsc]

Why would Ally or anyone for that matter deny 1st cent Biblical texts in favor of 7th cent Qur'an?

[kidsarocker]

you muslims are dead wrong and you don't even know yoiur Quran, I know of 2 verses that claim Yeshua died and raised

[Julio Kosters]

Lol! I agree with you, let give Dr.Craig this one cause he is struggling to win in the sense, No crucifixtion, No Christianity. But logically speaking, I dont think anyone can win a debate with the long or short ending of (Mark 16:18) which says: And with their hands they will pick up serpents and if they drink anything deadly it will not hurt them at all.

[az bando]

its not about who wins or loses, its about hearing both sides of the story and making ur own conclusions

[bayreuth79]

I wasn't aware that "Cannibal" crossed the Alps to attack Rome. Maybe he ate all the Romans? lol