Top Comments
All Comments (506)
-
Can we just appreciate what the song is and not talking about what should be done to it? It's a great song and it wouldn't be Silversun Pickups if you changed things about it.
-
@arthursnotking retreating back to the previous EQ, after the drums enter. The reason I feel her choice of legato is distasteful, even insulting, is because she fills 3:12-3:29 with such a bland sound, which ought to have been an artful movement of selective, rhythmic silence. The only improvement needed bass-wise for 0:00-3:12, in my opinion, is that she simply needs to play more rhythmically defined triplets (yes, triplets are hard to play, but that's no excuse for sloppy playing); fixing this
-
@arthursnotking Furthermore, what you describe on 4:15 is the ominous pink slipping downward into the imminent violent red accented by the dirty, echoing distortion on the guitar to which we all jam; which is why I feel there is only one true mood change, if you understand the mechanics to the song. What would have fixed 3:12-3:29 bass-wise would be to abandon the legato restricted choice of equalization and opt for more staccato/staccatissimo/marcato sound by raising the mid/high, while slowly
-
@pkConda I'm sorry but the foundation of the chord progression [bass line] is the last thing I notice when it comes time to reaching the chorus; sure it's nice to hear a balanced sound, but you remiss the other elements that truly have a bigger hand in separating the chorus from the verses. I also must disagree about the 'big mood shift', because the syncopated rhythm guitar coming front stage of the wall of sound completely changes the color of the song from a wistful blue to an ominous pink.
-
God damned great song.
-
my favorite:D i love it to death so many memories
-
@arthursnotking that was a mood shift at 3:12 sure, but the big mood shift is at 4:15.
I agree re: the bassist, but i think the monotony of the bass melody serves to highlight the bass shift during the chorus, which you definitely feel (especially since you gotta wait 2 minutes for it to come back, and its a great climax)
-
it sounds a little bit like Metric.
One of my top 10 bands - says a lot for a guy with grandchildren
lingsbord 6 months ago 47
This song will be played at my funeral, that's how important it is to me!
adeshaw123 3 months ago 7