How to Get a Patent Part 2
Top Comments
All Comments (14)
-
I know it's just an example, but horizontal platform would mean a chair is only infringing if seat is horizontal. Perhaps platform with four supports extending from the platform for placement on a support surface.
-
Anything under the sun that was made by man? Im affraid your wrong, Monsanto has layed a patent on a living organism (their seeds) which was most certainly not mad by "man". lol
-
who owns the patent on women?
-
Modified by a recent holding in KSR v Teleflex:
One of the ways in which a patent's subject matter can be proved obvious is by noting that there existed at the time of invention a known problem for which there was an obvious solution encompassed by the patent's claims.
In that, if it were known to be beneficial to add a 4th leg to a chair - its deemed obvious, and the application for patent will be rejected.
(Probably way to much information.. but there you are)
-
I will save you the trouble. The courts define obviousness by running through a set of tests from Grahm vs John Deere: 1. the scope and content of the prior art; 2. the level of ordinary skill in the art; 3. the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art; and 4. objective evidence of nonobviousness.
Which are: 1. commercial success; 2. long-felt but unsolved needs; and 3. failure of others.
-
Re cremepunK:
The three legged chair would be cited as prior art.
However it comes down to this:
Is the 4th leg obvious?
35 USC 103 A
A patent may not be obtained... if the differences between the subject matter sought to be patented and the prior art are such that the subject matter as a whole would have been obvious at the time the invention was made to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which said subject matter pertains.
-US Law-
-
In tht case, wouldnt it be that the at least 4 legs device as claimed is not inventive? Is this possible that this patent could be cited with the prior art of 3 legs device?
-
This Videa was very well put together and has helped me alot with some ideas i have.
-
I believe there is a patent office in europe you will have to apply for as well. This is true for each country and region.
-
i have several ideas i wud like 2 patent and i wud like to thank u 4 this video
Very articulate and knowledgable. Thank you.
Iamare 4 years ago 9
Are these law international?Will they be relevant in Europe aswell?
FashionINart 3 years ago 3