Hikaru no Go - Reborn [AU]
Uploader Comments (SemeTake)
Top Comments
-
This is well made, and the scenes match so well!! AND THE MUSIC CHOSE! How did you get numb?! It's so awesome!! It's unique and this is a very interesting idea. Hey, is it ok if someone i know mae a fanfic based on this?
-
This is really great :)
All Comments (70)
-
Ahhhhh very well worded, very well chosen. Beautiful amv. Keep making vids please :)
-
sounds like linken park
-
i love how numb is the background music, its so dramatic+exciting xD
in hikaru no go, shindo wasnt just pleading to akira for him to just wait for him, shindo's goal was to pass him, shindo's determination was just just overwhelming? :O
-
Excellent, really.
Very strong.
You should end it a few seconds later, because cut off the music like this is heart paining, else that, there's nothing more to say.
That was awesome! Is there a fanfic you based this on, or was it just all on its own? Either way, I like it. Good work!
FelisHaww 1 year ago
@FelisHaww Thank you very much for the review, I'm glad you liked the video :) there is no fanfic this is based on, though one of those who liked the vid started writing a fanfic based on this :) though it was never finished, sadly... heh thanks again :)
SemeTake 1 year ago
I'm not flaming about it... but this just isn't very good.
frankiethefrank 2 years ago
Could you please specify? I mean, were there some specific things that made you not like the vid, or was it just an overall feeling? :) I can see some things I would do differently now as it is an old vid, but I'd still like to know what I can improve next time :)
SemeTake 2 years ago
Well... the music is grating and very annoying, the pace is very slow and doesn't really change much, and the typography is very pixellated and cheap-looking. But I think the main problem is just... 'why?' - It doesn't say anything new, it doesn't add to any of the characters, and it's very direct and blunt, whereas the original cartoon is subtle and suggestive, and just... better.
Let me emphasize again I ain't flaming. But.. you asked :-)
frankiethefrank 2 years ago
@frankiethefrank Well, I kind of agree with you on the pace being slow... I made the vid a long time ago, and as I said before, I would do some things differently ") thank you for taking your time and pointing out my mistakes to me... however, on the question WHY: I made the vid purely for fun, and to satisfy my slash/shonenai urges :D I never tried, in any way, to make something better than the purely genius original work, which I agree is great :)
SemeTake 1 year ago